Via KHON, this news at the end of a nine year legal saga:
HONOLULU (KHON2) — An academic researcher who was severely injured in a lab explosion at University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa reached a $6.7 million settlement after an almost decade-long legal battle.
Dr. Thea Ekins-Coward lost a portion of her right arm when her experiment exploded back in March 2016.
Following the incident, the university denied liability, saying Ekins-Coward was an employee covered by limited workers’ compensation.
Here's her legal firm's public statement:
An academic researcher was seriously injured when her laboratory experiment exploded. The university who sponsored the research denied liability. The university first claimed that, as our client’s employer, her claims against it were barred by the workers’ compensation statutes. So, we obtained a ruling that our client was not the university’s employee, even though the university paid her a stipend and provided her certain benefits.
The university next blamed our client for using inappropriate and unsafe equipment. But we showed that the university approved the equipment, and that the university should have better trained our client on safety measures that should be taken when working with explosive gasses.
The settlement we achieved was calculated to take care of our client’s needs going forward. And as a result of the investigation, universities across the country changed their laboratory safety practices so that other researchers would not suffer similar injuries.
I hope the settlement ends this long and painful chapter for Dr. Ekins-Coward, who appears to have moved on with her life in science.
From the broad academic chemical/laboratory safety perspective, I simply do not think anymore (after the Beacon rainbow flame incident) that large settlements actually make a national impact. Individual PIs and researchers will definitely not hesitate to set up risky experiments because (I suspect) they are simply not experienced enough or not trained enough to recognize that (for example) a gas mixture of hydrogen and oxygen would require strict control of static electricity in the research environment.
Best wishes to Dr. Ekins-Coward.
I cannot help but also think that in today's clearly restricted funding environment, one possible outcome may be that schools will cut down on research safety oversight. I'm not sure that will have a dramatic impact on overall incidences of laboratory safety incidents in either direction, but it sure won't help.