Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Daily Pump Trap: 6/28/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 23 and June 27, there were 30 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 7 (23%) were academically connected.

Billerica, MA: Bruker is looking for a B.S./M.S./Ph.D. spectroscopist to perform method development for NMR; 3 years experience required.

¡Hola! : Dr. Reddy's Laboratory is looking for an experienced Ph.D. organic chemist to be a R&D manager in Mexico. Where in Mexico, you might ask? No se.

Irvine, CA: Allergan is looking for a B.S. chemist to perform analytical method development. 

Pleasanton, CA: Clorox desires a Ph.D. chemist to be a researcher into oxidation chemistry. Colloid and interfacial science experience preferred.

Oh, it's you again: Millenium is (once again) posting a "multiple positions open" ad on ACS Careers. Hmmm.

Interesting?: The American Cleaning Institute (formerly the Soaps and Detergents Association) wishes to hire a B.S. chemist for an administrative coordinator position in Washington, D.C. Huh.

That's one way to spend your postdoc: NYU-Abu Dhabi has posted an open position for a postdoc in synthetic organic / polymer chemistry. Huh.

SSSSSSSS: Alberta Sulphur Research Ltd. wishes to hire a B.S. analytical chemist to help with projects towards the removal of sulfur compounds from petroleum crude. Sounds interesting.

Oh, good luck there: ChemHost is hiring a M.S. chemist to be a quality assurance project manager; looks like you'll be spending a good amount of time looking over Chinese chemical manufacturing plants. Hmmmm. 

Monday, June 27, 2011

Itinerant chemists and chemistry's soft power

From this week's issue of Chemical and Engineering News, a letter that strikes a bit of jealousy in a young chemist's heart:
...When I graduated in 1948, chemist supply balanced demand, so I had constant employment with one company at one site for 60 years, which gave me a stable life. After 56 years, I still live in the same house; have experienced financial stability; learned an enormous amount about my company's widespread technology, allowing me to contribute to many areas; and enjoyed some successes during my career. 
This would be a rare expectation for today's graduates who, in their career, may be constantly moving from job to job and have no substantial roots. This situation will hasten the sinking esteem of chemistry in general because a chemist with only temporary roots in many communities will not be permitted to make significant contributions to local problems. [snip]
One influential politician with a chemistry background can have more influence than all the promotional programs ACS can produce. He or she can preach chemistry and protect us from the outrageous antichemistry statements circulating today in the media. Such local involvement is impossible for chemists whose roots are no deeper than those of itinerant farmworkers. Even those with permanent employment are so heavily loaded with work today that an exceedingly small number enter politics—it takes courage to request the necessary time off from work to enter politics at the risk of facing unemployment.
The American Chemical Society should be commended for its programs to help students, but the society should revisit the programs. Is it right to encourage the young to expend years devoted to the study of chemistry, plus the personal sacrifice, only to end up selling tools or appliances at Sears? Is it right for ACS to request financial support for these programs from chemists who are searching for employment? Is it possible that ACS might put the program on hold until equilibrium between supply and demand is reestablished?
In summary, we need to encourage chemists to enter the political arena to protect our reputation, and it cannot happen in today's environment where only ephemeral employment exists.
Edward G. Howard 
Hockessin, Del. 
I confess to being a little jealous of people like Mr./Dr. Howard. I certainly long for the ability to put down roots in a community and have time to love my neighbor (to borrow a phrase.) Maybe that time will come, but in our post-modern economy, staying in one place seems to be the greatest of luxuries.

While it's certainly tempting to focus on the nostalgia in Mr./Dr. Howard's letter, there is a real truth in his statements. Near-permanent employment in one place allows chemists to join a community and be influential for chemistry. Itinerancy, while good for some corporations and lots of moving companies, does little to grow chemistry's "soft power".

Friday, June 24, 2011

JOBLESS CHEMISTS STRIKING OUT

Josh Bloom, a former Wyeth chemist, gets his say in the New York Post editorial section on #chemjobs and whether we need more scientists, and boy, does he bring the heat:
To trim expenses, companies began to outsource research to India and China. It started as a trickle, but soon became a tsunami, leaving many thousands of highly intelligent and well-trained professionals with nothing to do -- a shameful waste of talent.
My colleagues and I at Wyeth watched helplessly as one company after another shed employees in huge numbers -- 300,000 since 2000. When Pfizer -- facing the looming expiration of its Lipitor patent and a poor research pipeline -- bought Wyeth for its portfolio of products in 2009, it cut about 25,000 jobs, with more to come. Most of the combined company's research sites have either closed or are in the process of doing so. Before long, the world's largest pharmaceutical company will be conducting very little research in the US.
So, what do thousands of unemployed chemists do? Good question. The employment section of the latest (June 13) issue of our trade magazine, Chemical and Engineering News, is hardly promising. It lists a total of one industrial position and two college tenure-track faculty openings in the US. (Of course, there are online sites with more jobs, but the situation there is still bleak).
And good luck finding a high-school teaching job. Last year, one of my old colleagues decided he wanted to teach science in New Jersey -- but found out that not a single position was available in the entire state. Previous industry casualties had probably filled the few openings.
It wasn't always this way. The mid-1990s saw a shortage of chemists, with drug companies hiring like crazy. Bristol-Meyers Squibb, for one, offered cars as signing bonuses. But the company has fired over 10,000 employees since 2000; one wonders if any of them are now living in those cars.
I think I could argue with the tone* and quibble with the facts. That being said, I think it's a bleak but fair picture of what we're facing (and I gotta love the CJ-esque look at C&EN.) It's too bad that it's come to this.

Best wishes to all of us.

*The bit about working at the Gap (earlier in the article) is a little much. 

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Goodbye, Org Prep Daily.

Milkshake is hanging up the blogging hat, looks like. I'll miss it. There's a wealth of chemistry to be learned from just the comments, much less the beautifully annotated preps.

Best of luck, Milkshake. It was a great 5 years. Sigh. 

Chart of the week: manufacturing is lagging


To make a long story short, BLS' Job Openings and Labor Turnover survey suggests that manufacturing is the  sector that is moving the least (next to government, that is, which is shrinking these days.) Oh, dear. 

Daily Pump Trap: 6/23/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 21 and 22, there were 7 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 2 (29%) were academically connected.

More analyst positions: DuPont is looking for a couple more analytical chemists: a M.S./Ph.D. position in Mobile, AL performing analytical method development and plant support and a M.S./Ph.D. position in Midland, MI being a GC/LC subject matter expert and a GLP study director.

Bartlesville, OK: Chevron is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to perform research into polymerization. Previous experience with polyolefin polymerization or Ziegler-Natta chemistry desired. Looks to be a entry-level position.

And a pony would be nice: A group at Harvard Medical School would like to hire a postdoc: "Projects focused on the design of molecularly defined living and inert surfaces that limit inflammation and thrombosis. Experience in bio-orthogonal chemistry, thin films, genetic engineering, and drug delivery is desirable." I'm going to guess that it's just one of those four fields. Otherwise, are you frickin' kidding me? This is like science fiction, where a character can have a Ph.D. in theoretical astrophysics and be a combat pilot, all before the age of 30 or so.

A broader look: Monster, Careerbuilder, Indeed and USAjobs.gov show 297, 632, 3550 and 95 positions respectively. 

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Process Wednesday: Handling hydrazoic acid safely

A recent paper in Organic Process Research and Development* has a nice section on hydrazoic acid issues concerning the use of sodium azide to displace an aromatic nitro group; the aromatic azide would then participate in a cyclization to an indazole:
Initial hazard testing focused on the evaluation of hydrazoic acid levels in the head space of the reaction or workup mixtures, as this compound is both highly toxic and can form explosive gas mixtures with oxygen or nitrogen above concentrations of 8-12%. Some variation in the lower decomposition level of hydrazoic acid has been reported; however, a recent study appeared to confirm that detonation below 10 vol% should not be possible.  
Maintaining a basic pH during the reaction mixture should ensure that any hydrazoic aid remained ionized and would thus limit levels in the head space and as such was considered desirable. After some screening it was found that addition of 1 equiv of 2,6-lutidine to the reaction mixture served to maintain a basic pH and has no detrimental effect on the reaction profile or rate. Hence, this base was added prior to heating any reactions. Headspace monitoring using FT-IR indicated undetectable levels of hydrazoic acid in the headspace throughout the course of the reaction using a nitrogen sweep of 16 mL/min.  
On the basis of comparison with CO2 in the headspace and the detection limit of the instrument, this data implied a worse-case hydrazoic acid level in the headspace of 60 ppm with this nitrogen sweep, and it was clear that only a very modest nitrogen sweep (about 0.02 mL/min) would be required to keep concentration of hydrazoic acid below 5 vol% which compares favorale with the lower decomposition limit of 10 vol%. As such there was no significant risk with this aspect of the reaction. 
I think this section is a nice example of a good way to approach potentially hazardous reagent issues. Finding out the minimum limits of toxicity/danger, using monitoring equipment and then keeping levels well-below the minimums seems to be a good strategy to me. A good thought process for all of us.

*Wallace et al, Org. Process Res. Dev. ASAP.  

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Daily Pump Trap, 6/21/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 16 and June 20, there have been 111 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 7 (6%) are academically connected and 1 (1%) is from Kelly Scientific.

Freeport, TX: BASF is looking for a B.S./M.S. chemist with 6+ years experience in plant support to be a QC/QA specialist. You'll be in the acrylic monomers business unit.

Sunnyvale, CA: Serious Materials, Inc. is a startup working on liquid crystals and other polymeric materials. They're looking for a B.S./M.S./Ph.D. chemist or materials scientist.

Experience matters: Genentech is looking for a senior Ph.D. analytical chemist to run their analytical support group within Discovery Chemistry. 10+ years experience in drug discovery desired.

Also, Genentech is looking for a Ph.D. organic chemist for its process chemistry group. 1-5 years of experience desired, although the following is a little confusing:

Candidates with over nine years of experience and significant industry accomplishments in terms of marketed products/industrial innovation will be considered for the Senior Scientist role.

Look, if you got a Ph.D. with over nine years experience and all of these industry accomplishments, shouldn't you be offering a fairly senior title? "Associate Principal Scientist" would seem to be appropriate.

Over there: Shanghai Syncores Technologies ("a wholly owned subsidiary of  Zhejiang Huahai Pharmaceuticals")  is looking for group leaders, from bench-level to senior VP. 5+ years experience in the pharmaceutical industry desired.

MERRRRRRRRRCK!: Are you a chemist? Do you like chemistry? Merck wants to know if you want to be a senior tax analyst in New Jersey or a customer category manager in Bentonville, Arkansas (working with WalMart, no doubt.) Look, folks, are you freakin' kidding me? 

Monday, June 20, 2011

A shift away from pharma/biotech to chemical companies?


This week's Chemical and Engineering News has an interesting set of contrasting articles. Lisa Jarvis has a cover story on the challenges that biotechs are facing as their pharma partners are (in some cases) breaking off collaborations on clinical candidates. Jarvis' article starts with the story of Michael Morrissey, CEO of Exelexis (a Evans group alum, it appears) and the story of the company's broken-off collaboration with BMS. According to another article in this week's issue, the biotech sector as a whole was steadily profitable in 2010 for the second year in a row. However, R&D funding is said to be under pressure (unsurprising, really.) 

In the same issue, there's coverage of the American Chemistry Council and the relatively flush times they're experiencing. It's an unusually happy story for these days: chemical companies use natural gas as a feedstock and a source of energy. With the advent of cheap natural gas (thanks to hydraulic fracturing, I suspect) and growing overseas demand for their products, US chemical companies' profit margins are going up. 

Not many bright spots for chemistry employment in the US for this week, it seems. It will be interesting to see if chemistry R&D positions will begin to come from chemical companies, as opposed to pharma/biotech. One can only hope. 

Good luck to all of us. 

Friday, June 17, 2011

3 ml syringes

A list of small, useful things (links):
Am I missing something? Put it in the comments! 

Have a good weekend! 

Rays of sunshine

There are clouds there, too.
Photo credit: Flickr user **Mary**
I've been getting just a couple of notes from folks who are managing to find positions. While it's not exactly the Season of Recovery, it's good news. (Glen Ernst over at JAEP just posted that he was able to find a job at an academic institution, for example.)

Uh, if there's other good news to be had, let's have it!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Request thread

Sorry for the posting schedule being a little weird here, but it's a little tough to find that quiet morning hour to post these days.

A question: what would you like to see me cover? What would you like to see me cover less?

I'll surprise no one and say that I have a general posting schedule during the week: I try to comment on anything #chemjobs-related in the latest C&EN on Monday, I talk about grad school / learning issues on Tuesday and management/boss/business issues on Thursday. Wednesday and Friday are humor/whatever days and Tuesday/Thursday is committed to the Daily Pump Trap.

Also, what long-term projects would you like me to work on for the 2011-2012 season?

Daily Pump Trap: 6/16/11 edition

Good morning! (such as it is.) Between June 14 and June 15, there were 19 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 2 (11%) are academically connected.

Analystapalooza: Well, maybe I'm getting a little ahead of myself. Eastman Chemical desires 2 Ph.D. analytical chemists, one for separation science and one for electrochemistry-related work. Also, Boehringer Ingelheim wishes to hire a B.S./M.S./Ph.D. analyst (with experience) for its Columbus, OH API facility. Infinity Pharmaceuticals desires an experienced Ph.D. analytical chemist to run its analytical program on its development side.

Not done yet -- cosmetics: Avon is looking for a Ph.D. analytical chemist at its Suffolk, NY site. 5+ years experience is desired.

Crystals!: Lilly is looking for 2 Ph.D. chemists, one with a great deal of experience in crystal engineering and one with 3+ years of experience. Good news for their development side, maybe.

Pontiac, MI: AkzoNobel is looking for a B.S. chemist to be a production support chemist. 5 years experience in paints and/or coatings is required. You'll be performing "8D analysis", which sounds like a QA function. Huh.

Hayward, CA: Pioneer Hi-Bred is looking for a Ph.D. biochemist for a post-doctoral position. Research experience in insecticidal proteins is desired. 

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

The last seminar you attended


[Mild applause]

Moderator: Thank you, Professor Jones, for a wonderful seminar on new techniques in nitrosation of aromatic compounds. And now, Professor Jones will be happy to answer any questions you might have.
  1. Professor Jones, could you go back to your section on the mechanism? [clickclickclickclickclick] Oh. [awkward pause] No question. 
  2. Professor Jones! So good to see you again! [Inside joke about conference 10 years ago]
  3. Is there going to be wine afterwards? Yes? Thanks. 
  4. [throat clearing] Dr. Zhervokvsky at Soviet Institute of Chemistry showed in Archives of Soviet Industrial Chemistry in 1962 all your work forty years ago -- maybe you should educate yourself in his work!
  5. I see in the NMR that you showed on slide 23 that there were some small peaks at 8.1 ppm. Do you know what that impurity is?
  6. This reminds me of the time that I was talking to [questioner's famous graduate adviser] and he said that [really, really, really, really long pointless anecdote about nitric acid]. Well, I didn't have a question, I just was reminiscing. 
  7. Do you think a kinetic isotope experiment would be useful for the reaction on slide 15? 
  8. The yield in that one reaction was kind of low, wasn't it? 
  9. Ah, ah, ah, yes, Professor Jones. As you're well aware of Professor Takahashamata's work in [really obscure journal] and its application to [subject near and dear to questioner's heart, irrelevant to seminar], do you have any comment on that? 
  10.  (question no one can hear) (Highlight to read.)
  11. Will there be wine afterwards? Excellent.

Process Wednesday: maximum stirrable volume

What is the maximum stirrable
volume of a beer stein?
Photo credit: thenibble.com
Continuing with Kilomentor's comments on reactor volume, he comments on maximum stirrable volume:
In order to minimize the number of vessels used in a step, the workup of a reaction is preferably conducted in the reactor vessel. In order to calculate the highest possible kilograms of intermediate product that can be produced in a particular reactor in a single run one needs to first determine what point in the protocol requires the largest stirred volume. Then the protocol is rescaled so that at that point this volume is equal to the maximum stirrable volume of the particular reactor. For example, suppose the protocol you are going to follow will produce 45 grams of purified product and at the point of maximum volume in this procedure the combined organic and aqueous solutions are 500 mL. if the maximum stirrable volume for the reactor you propose using in production is 2200 litres then the maximum throughput per run will be (2200/500) X 45 = 198 kg. Now if the target of your project will require you to make 450 kg of this intermediate, you will need at least three runs of this step because the maximum amount two runs can give is 396 kg. 
Now if you could modify the protocol so that at the point of maximum volume the volume were only 440 litres, you could make the 450 kg of material in just 2 runs. Providing a margin of safety against shortfalls by planning for 3 runs may be the wisest course of action.
As opposed to minimum stirrable volume, this is a concept that applies to lab-scale chemistry. Ever been working up a reaction in a 500 mL flask and found that you need to add 1 L of water to quench?

When you're planning a reaction for the first time, it's not a terrible idea to add up all the volume you're adding to a reaction and see if you're going to exceed the maximum stirrable volume of your flask -- it might save you some time.  

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Daily Pump Trap: 6/14/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 9 and June 13, there were 22 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 6 (27%) are academically connected.

Rolla, MO: Brewer Science is once again looking; this time, for a A.A./B.S. chemist to be a Research Associate III in the Advanced Packaging R&D group. Looks like this position is half bench chemistry, half project management.

Polymers!: Dow Chemical is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be an associate scientist in their polyurethanes process group. 1 year industrial experience required, as well as experience with ASPEN process simulation software.

They're back!: Halcyon Molecular is looking for an instrumentation technician to repair and maintain an absolute fleet of HPLCs and GCs. Uh, good luck with that one.

Helpful or not?: Amway is looking for a B.S./M.S./Ph.D. analytical chemist to perform method development and other analysis on cosmetics. They're advertising the salary range, (72-82), which I find interesting. Helpful or not helpful? I dunno. Southwestern Michigan, if that's your thing.

Iselin, NJ: BASF desires a Ph.D. chemist to perform heterogenous catalysis research. 1 year experience desired.

Zeroes!: Total Petrochemicals is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to work on styrene exploratory research. 0-3 years of postdoctoral work or experience in petrochemicals desired.

Lovely Baltimore: Goucher College desires a B.S. chemist to be its stockroom manager and its departmental chemical hygiene officer. Could be a great job!

One of the coolest jobs in chemistry: The Chemical Safety Board is looking for investigators!

One more for southwestern MI: Kalexsyn is looking for medicinal/organic chemists at all levels, primarily focusing on M.S./Ph.D.-level folks. Kalamazoo is home to a competitive Wiffle ball league, among other things.

Monday, June 13, 2011

Chemical engineers fare better than chemists. In other news, dog bites man.


From today's edition of Chemical and Engineering News, an article on the hiring of chemical engineers in the biotech world by Sophie Rovner:
Chemical engineering employment is “always steady, with fewer ups and downs in the job market” than chemists have to contend with, says David G. Jensen, managing director for biopharmaceutical life sciences at Kincannon & Reed, a Waynesboro, Va., executive search firm. “I’ve been doing this work for 25 years and have never seen a downtime for biotech chemical process development engineers,” adds Jensen, who writes extensively about careers and also moderates the American Association for the Advancement of Science’s online Science Careers Forum. 
Robust demand for chemical engineers may explain why wages are holding up well in the profession. In a survey of salaries for 2011 bachelor’s degree graduates, chemical engineers placed first, with an average salary offer of $66,886, according to the National Association of Colleges & ­Employers. 
The American Chemical Society’s own surveys of members consistently show that chemical engineering graduates receive higher salaries and are more likely to hold permanent full-time jobs than graduates with degrees in chemistry (C&EN, March 14, page 52).
Rovner's article is pretty interesting, with a couple of in-depth looks at what chemical engineers do on a regular basis. A small point: Rovner doesn't cover (IIRC) what I see as the broad economic sweep, which is that the smaller companies that were looking at bio-based materials during the 2007-2008 oil price spike (e.g. the Amyrises of the world) are now large enough and developed enough to be hiring chemical engineers to develop their processes to larger scale. I wonder if I'm right.

Another note: Hanson's short article (also linked above) is worth reading, if only to see that the broader economic trends are hitting chemical engineers as well.

It's apparent to me that if you're mathematically, mechanically and chemically inclined, you should think long and hard about a career in chemical engineering. I'll note (said the fox, looking at the grapes) that I have worked with chemical engineers a number of times. I've never envied what they do, but I have always envied* their salaries.

*I'm not much a salary envier, I might note; if I was, I don't think I could deal with life very well. 

Friday, June 10, 2011

What is the minimum amount of equipment needed to run a chemistry business?

In the entrepreneurship thread, the discussion turned to how to set up a small business performing chemistry:
Anon060720110900a: The idea that anyone other than tenured professors with a LOT of clout can just go off and found a science/chemistry based startup is TOTAL bunk. Of course, you can find the one or two cases in which it happened (google Halcyon Molecular). But seriously, the Zuckerberg model of "start the company from your dorm room" works great for software, but once you realize that you need fume hoods, AFMs, TEM's, compliance with federal/state/municipal hazard laws, etc, the model falls apart real quick. 
Anon060820111000a: I hear such space exists in the Silicon Valley with all the permits to do chemistry, and landlord offers proper waste disposal in the rent which is about $5000 per month. They don’t provide chemicals, glassware or Scifinder access. Better have a client list with orders or a big bankroll.
What's the smallest amount of glassware, etc that you need to set up a lab? My list would consist of:
  • A hood
  • A small set of glassware
  • A heating mantle
  • Temperature probe (or thermometer)
  • Flash column
  • TLC plates
  • Rotovap
  • Access to an HPLC and/or an NMR
  • SciFinder access (or a nearby university)
  • A laptop (combination lab notebook and lab radio)
I think that's about all I would need, but I'm going to guess that I've just listed off about $10,000 worth of equipment. 

The operating overhead for chemistry is just really high -- that hurts small business formation and I'm not sure what to do with it. Readers, what say you? What's the smallest amount of equipment you need? 

The US' newest export: assistant professors?


From the Washington Post a couple weeks back, Matthew Stremlau (a postdoc at Broad) writes about working as a (visiting) scientist in China:
The global science landscape is radically different from what it was when I started graduate school 10 years ago. Opportunities for cutting-edge science are sprouting in many other countries. China stands out. But there are plenty of others. India, Brazil and Singapore built world-class research institutes. Saudi Arabia aggressively recruits researchers for its King Abdullah University of Science and Technology. With a staggering $10 billion endowment there — larger than MIT’s — American scientists no longer need to suffer through Boston’s endless winters. Not to be outdone, Abu Dhabi opened the Masdar Institute of Science and Technology in 2009. These emerging powers have a voracious appetite for good scientists. So they’re trying to poach ours. [snip] 
Talented scientists in this country often fall through the cracks because they can’t get funding. Agencies are deluged with applications and often have to reject as many as 90 percent of the proposals they receive. Unfortunately, the situation is likely to deteriorate further as budget cuts limit the resources available for research. So I’ve started encouraging my friends to think more creatively about their careers. Go to China, I tell them. Or Singapore or Brazil or the Middle East. If the United States can’t fund its scientific talent, find a country that will.
In Beth Halford's "Too Many PhDs" article, we heard from Amir Hoveyda that perhaps US scientists should be thinking about heading overseas to make their way into the academic world. John Schwab also mentioned that perhaps even industrially-oriented young organic chemists need to be following their passions internationally.

I suspect Stremlau would agree with me that the international science boom (represented mostly by advancing economies in the Middle East and Asia) will not last forever and will produce winners and losers. New universities may not succeed in translating money into good science and the political and economic winds may shift once again. You can't buy your way into a great science culture without changing much of your political and economic system*; many countries might balk at the price in terms of relinquishing governmental control.

I think these issues (the concerns about young postdocs heading overseas) are mostly sideshows to the real question: who will receive government funding in the future and how long will they have to wait? As crazy as it sounds, I believe that the majority of the time, the current grants system probably selects the best science to fund. But there is continued dissatisfaction with the system. I hope it will probably (hopefully) culminate in a reworking to allow younger scientists to receive more funding, earlier. Otherwise, we're making a lot of youngish professors suffer -- and they'll consider going elsewhere if the suffering is less there.

In an (unusually) optimistic conclusion, the US commitment to science is long and deep and I suspect will continue on its current funding trend for many, many years.* In the end, though, I am all for other countries investing in science and trying to poach young US scientists; to paraphrase Churchill, science, science is better than war, war.

*OK, so China and Singapore are probably going to test that assertion pretty strongly. 
**In the coming years, what's going to take the bigger hit? DoD or NIH? My bet is DoD -- yours? 

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Fewer layoffs, more firing?

You didn't coordinate with Biology to
get those assays completed in time?
Photo credit: sodahead.com
I enjoy reading the blog of Tom Ricks, the Washington Post's former longtime Pentagon correspondent. (He's since moved to the Center for a New American Security as a defense analyst.)

Ricks enjoys covering the Navy's habit of routinely firing the commanding officer (CO) of its ships and other shore units. Here, Ricks notes Commander Mike Varney, who was recently relieved for mishandling sensitive documents aboard the USS Seawolf. Here's the head of the Navy's Norfolk, VA shipyard, removed for his "command environment." Here's a post for a pair of COs removed for not stopping hazing amongst the crew of the USS Ponce.

I think Ricks thinks that the Navy's tradition of not hesitating to remove the CO of a unit is a good one, in that it's better to address a leadership problem sooner rather than later. While it certainly can be harsh (and it's well-known that captains can be removed for more-or-less bad luck), the Navy allows its ship captains to have quite a bit of freedom in their leadership styles in return.*

Would a policy like this work in the pharma industry? There aren't equivalents to ship captains in pharma, but I have noted that project managers have a special leadership role. I haven't been around long enough to note whether or not project managers get summarily removed for "lack of leadership" or other "Hey, you're just not getting the job done" issues.

Readers, what say you? Should pharma managers be removed from their positions more often (as opposed to waiting for layoffs or other attrition?) Have you seen it happen?

*It should also be noted that removal from command doesn't necessarily mean that you're immediately removed from the Navy; you're probably not going to commanding any more units, though. 

Daily Pump Trap: 6/9/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 7 and June 8, there were 7 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website.

Good news?: Cubist in Boston is looking for a B.S./M.S. chemist to be a research associate with organic chemistry lab experience.

Coffee is for closers: Setaram is looking for a B.S. chemist to be a salesperson for their line of calorimetry instruments. Looks like you're going to need to travel. West Coast residents desired.

A broader look: For the search term "chemist", Monster, Careerbuilder and Indeed are showing (respectively) 303, 591 and 3629 positions. USAjobs.gov is showing 100 positions for the search term "chemist." 

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

11 ways to really irritate your summer lab mentor

Summer students, it's early June, so it means that you're probably settling into the lab you'll be in for the next two to three months or so. Here's a few ways of getting back at the person you'll be working for/with:
  1. On a regular basis, ask your mentor "Why should the government fund this research?" She'll love you for it. 
  2. If they show you their secret stash of equipment, say loudly, "Hey, how come you're not sharing this stuff with your labmates?"
  3. Dirty glassware isn't worth cleaning -- ever. 
  4. Go through the drawers around their lab bench and loudly point out any unlabeled flasks of compounds. 
  5. Ask, "Do you have a boyfriend (or girlfriend)?" If yes, ask them "When was the last time you got to spend time with them?" If no, ask them "Why not?"
  6. If your group meeting presentation isn't going well, turn to your lab mentor and say, "You didn't prepare me well enough for this!"
  7. Ask them what the departmental Chemical Hygiene Plan is. 
  8. Every Tuesday, ask them to explain every single step of an experiment and what chemical principles are involved. Make sure they look everything up in a textbook. 
  9. Remind them that you're thinking about engineering or medical school. 
  10. If they're really, really, really messy, regularly clean up everything spotlessly. They won't be able to function. 
  11. Repeat after me: "Hey, what kind of jobs can you get after you graduate?"

Process Wednesday: minimum stirrable volume

How much distance between the blades and the bottom of
the reactor? Probably doesn't matter, right?
Photo credit: phxequip.com
Reading through Kilomentor's archives, one finds a treasure trove of information for the young process chemist. This morning, the concept of 'minimum stirrable volume':
The minimum stirrable volume is exactly what the name teaches. It is the minimum volume of liquid needed in the reactor so that the turning stirrer paddles effectively stir the reactor contents. To some extent this minimum stirrable volume depends upon what is being stirred and what will happen during the initial stage of the reaction of interest. For example, a homogeneous solution in which an exothermic refluxing occurs at the beginning of the reaction may only need the moving blades to touch the liquid surface because gas evolution and thermal convection are going to move the homogeneous liquid phase around. At the other extreme, if zinc powder, tin granules or magnesium turning need to be swept up off the bottom of the reactor, the immersion of the stirrer blades probably needs to be complete and the stirring rapid. 
The reason chemists, who are more accustomed to working in the laboratory tend to forget the minimum stirring volume constraint is that two of the most common laboratory stirrer types are the magnetic stirrer and the crescent bladed overhead mechanical type. The magnetic stir bar on the bottom of the flask so that the minimum stirrable volume is very small while the crescent bladed stirrer is very often set up with its curved edge nestled up against the bottom of the round bottomed flask in which it is installed so that again the minimum stirrable volume is close to zero.
It's been a while since I used a stir bar in any of my reactions; that being said, it still influences my thinking quite a bit. It only takes one situation in which you note that your reaction volume doesn't reach the bottom of the agitator blades to remind you of this concept. It's funny how forgetting little details like 'minimum stirrable volume' can really ruin your day...

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Chart of the week: the tyranny of the negative slope in jobs

From the Washington Post, a breakout of job losses and gains for the Great Recession, graphically represented below:

Note: BLS manufacturing statistics for the chemicals subsector does include the pharma manufacturing as well. 

Daily Pump Trap: 6/7/11 edition

Good morning! Between June 2 and June 6, there were 83 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 4 (5%) were academically connected.

The NMR guy/gal: The University of Nebraska-Lincoln is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be a "director of research instrumentation."

Wanted -- good hands: Exquadrum, Inc. is looking for a B.S./M.S./Ph.D. chemist to perform research into energetic materials chemistry. Relevant experience desired, polymer chemistry experience welcomed.

DNA -> money: Ontorii is a startup that is looking to make therapeutic oligonucleotides; they're looking for a M.S./Ph.D. chemist to perform synthesis of said nucleic acids. Automated synthesizer experience desired.

Huh: Fairmount Minerals is looking for a "highly trained" organic chemist to be a process chemist. 5+ years industrial experience desired. I have no idea what an industrial sand company wants with an organic chemist.

Not using the f-word: Pacific Northwest National Laboratories (located in beautiful, isolated Richland, Washington) is looking for a communications manager for its Fundamental and Computational Sciences division.

Wow, Merck: Of the 83 positions, 63 (76%) were from Merck. Just when you thought it was safe to click "Find A Job", they're back. Are you a chemist? Do you love chemistry? Want to be an animal services technician? How about a clinical veterinarian? Or a maintenance mechanic (well, those folks actually make pretty good money, I'll bet.) 

Monday, June 6, 2011

Joe Francisco's solution to #chemjobs: entrepreneurship

Prof. Joe Francisco
Photo credit: purdue.edu
ACS immediate past president Joseph A. Francisco writes in this week's C&EN about jobs and his potential solution to chemistry unemployment problems:
During my presidential succession, I have focused on one overarching theme—to ensure that aspiring chemists and seasoned professionals in the U.S. have the skill sets, resources, and external environment to build and sustain a robust workforce in the U.S. Given the historic levels of job loss in our enterprise over the past few years, including thousands of R&D jobs for chemists, [emphasis CJ's] I felt this was one of my most important priorities. [snip]
I appointed a task force charged with providing recommendations for how the American Chemical Society can play a vital role in helping the chemical enterprise in the U.S. remain the most innovative and entrepreneurial in the world. This Task Force on Innovation was headed by Harvard University chemistry professor and entrepreneur George M. Whitesides and consisted of eminent individuals from industry, academia, and government, all with experience in entrepreneurship.[snip]
The task force noted that the nature of innovation is changing. Over the past 15 years, the process of transforming ideas into marketable innovations within the chemical enterprise has undergone dramatic change. Innovation that disrupts existing competitive markets and creates new customers has slowed.[snip]
Nevertheless, large companies want to rebuild proprietary positions in high-margin products. They may not be innovating fast enough to compete globally, however, and they now appear to be turning to others to develop innovative products. The source of that innovation could be universities and/or start-ups. The task force found no intrinsic reason why chemistry start-ups could not be commercially successful and, in fact, documented numerous such enterprises.
In light of these trends, the task force made recommendations that fall into four major categories.
  • First, it recommended that ACS develop a single organizational unit—a “technological farmers market.” ACS is already doing much to help entrepreneurs, and these activities will continue. The new unit is envisioned as a one-stop virtual portal, supporting entrepreneurs by facilitating more affordable access to resources that would foster the creation of small companies from start-ups. Relevant resources might include information about how to start a company, management expertise, links to key services, and a list of potential mentors. [snip]
  • Second, the task force recommended that ACS increase its advocacy of policies at the federal and state level to improve the business environment for entrepreneurs and start-up companies. The task force suggested that ACS urge and support reforms within the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office to ensure more accurate patents and faster issuance. Incidentally, ACS has suggested to PTO that the society’s talented unemployed members might be of assistance to patent examiners. [emphasis CJ's] The task force also outlined a number of financial policies that could encourage large companies to partner with small ones to promote entrepreneurship. These include preferential tax treatment for repatriated income invested in U.S.-based developers of technology and making the R&D tax credit simpler and permanent.
  • Third, the task force urged ACS to partner more vigorously with academic institutions and other relevant organizations to promote awareness of career pathways and educational opportunities that involve entrepreneurship. The task force had several interesting suggestions that will be pursued by staff and governance units.
  • Finally, the task force determined that ACS should increase public awareness of the value of early-stage entrepreneurship in the chemical enterprise with focused media coverage and information targeted to federal agencies that support chemistry. In addition, ACS should provide ways to recognize entrepreneurs publicly in order to increase their visibility and enhance their opportunities for success.
A couple of comments:

Entrepreneurship again? At some point in the near future, I should do a survey of all the different solutions that people have suggested to improve the chemistry employment situation. Among the top five must be this thought that chemists need to found their own companies and strike out on their own. While I think this might be a stopgap solution that might employ a small amount of very experienced chemists, and a moderate amount of mid-career professionals and young chemists, I just don't see this as a broad-based solution. I hope I'm wrong.

I hear the microwave in the kitchen!: I suspect that ACS' policy has always been to support the idea that we should support "preferential tax treatment for repatriated income invested in U.S.-based developers of technology and making the R&D tax credit simpler and permanent." While I suppose this might (in a bank-shot fashion) help chemical entrepreneurs, I suspect that the effects will be pretty minimal.

An unalloyed good: I sense from the occasional ACS comments in C&EN that the senior management of the Society is aware of the dissatisfaction of their members due to the extraordinary economic circumstances of the moment. That Prof. Francisco (or his staff) is writing about the issue and attempting address it is good news; perhaps this fall, the new ACS presidential candidates can address the issue full-force.

Best wishes to all of us. 

Friday, June 3, 2011

Unemployment number up 0.1% to 9.1%; U6 at 15.8%

Fresh electrons from BLS: the official unemployment rate for May 2011 is up 0.1% to 9.1%. The broader measurement of unemployment (U6) is down 0.1% to 15.8%.

Non-farm payroll went up by a relatively small 54,000. Can't tell if this is bad news, but it sure isn't good news. 

Green rubber stoppers

A list of small useful things (links):

Cheating: things oral exams can fix (but not scalable)

It's not fun to compare the salaries of doctors to chemists, but it is fun to compare the testing regimens to get into medical school versus graduate school. Also, it's terribly amusing to see what people will do to get around that testing. From Bruce Schneier comes a story of the cheater-in-the-middle:
Police allege he used a pinhole camera and wireless technology to transmit images of the questions on a computer screen back to his co-conspirator, Ruben, at the University of British Columbia.
Investigators believe Ruben then tricked three other students, who thought they were taking a multiple choice test for a job to be an MCAT tutor, into answering the questions.
The answers were then transmitted back by phone to Rezazadeh-Azar, as he continued on with the test in Victoria, police allege.
I would find it terribly amusing to attempt to cheat during an oral exam or your thesis defense. "The pKa of that compound? Hold on a sec..."

[Obviously, there are a heck of a lot more people trying to get into medical school than graduate school. Multiple choice tests are eminently scalable; oral exams are not.]  

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Interview feedback: an idea whose time has come?

Jim Austin at ScienceCareers points to a blogpost by Alison Vaillancourt on getting feedback from interviews:
It's a short essay; there's not a lot of advice there, and Vaillancourt really never answers the question. But two things make it worth reading. First, Vaillancourt describes the advice she long gave to people who had asked her whether they should provide feedback, before a recent experience altered her perspective: Don't tell losing candidates why they lost, she advised. Tell them why the winning candidate won. That would have worked for me: It accentuates positives, but it also would have told me what I needed to do to succeed in future interviews. 
Vaillancourt goes on to describe a situation where she did not do her best in an interview, and received some frank feedback on her performance.

I think this could be (and should be) done at most companies that hire chemists; I'm guessing that it would not add to the cost of an on-site interview to send an electronic form back to the non-hired candidate that gave some short feedback. Comments on perceived technical skill, social/'fit' issues with the group that you're going to work with, comments on communication could all be written up -- you could easily imagine a multiple-choice form that would be sent back to the candidate, along with the (sad) rejection phone call or letter.

It's my hope that companies will adopt this practice, but I'm not holding my breath. Sigh. 

Daily Pump Trap: 6/2/11 edition

Good morning! Between May 26 and June 1, there were 37 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 14 (38%) of these are academically connected and one (3%) is from Kelly Scientific.

Nice to see, I suppose: Eli Lilly is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be a researcher in pharmaceutical solid state chemistry; they're looking for someone with 5+ years experience, academic or industrial. I'll bet the number of folks who have academic experience in organic solid-state chemistry would fit on a city bus comfortably.

This one's for the organickers: A postdoc position (2 years from degree) with Targacept, in Winston-Salem, NC. And...

Oh, dear: Proteostasis Therapeutics in Cambridge, MA is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be a medicinal chemist. "PhD in organic chemistry or equivalent is required with 1-4 year post-doctoral/pharmaceutical experience for Scientist level and 3-8 years post-doctoral/pharmaceutical experience for Senior Scientist level."

In one sense, this is good, in that they're willing to consider folks with 3+ years postdoctoral experience. In another sense, this is bad, in that there are folks out there who have more than 3 years postdoc experience who haven't found positions. But that's to be expected with the 2008-201? employment recession in chemistry; it's just my hope that it doesn't become a hardened expectation to be hired.

Cambridge, again: Vertex is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to become a DMPK specialist. Some experience desired. 

SoCal, too: Hitachi (Irvine, CA) is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be a member of a research team looking at polymer technology. Experience with biochemistry and polymer synthesis desired.

And points south: A PI is looking for a B.S. chemist to be a lab coordinator; experience with polymer and small molecule MS characterization is desired.

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

A helpful guide for your next research meeting


Process Wednesday: yeah, make up that sample any way you want.

I don't know about other chemists, but I know that I'm tempted to take samples from reactions and take a squirt of this and a squirt of that and chuck it into the ol' HPLC to monitor the reaction. Our mentor-by-literature, Neal Anderson, suggests that's not such a great idea with his guidelines for sample preparation for in-process controls:
  • Dilute sample properly. Dilution effectively slows or quenches reactions, allowing for reliable assays. 
  • Consistently measure volume of diluent. Use volumetric flasks to prepare dilutions. 
  • Accurately measure sample to be diluted. Deliver aliquot for dilution by a microliter syringe or volumetric pipette. Quickly weigh solid samples. If it is necessary to deliver quantities larger than those a pipette can accommodate, weigh the aliquot and dilute. 
  • Be consistent about order of dilution
  • Be sure that the sample is completely dissolved. This is particularly important if the sample purity is to be assessed. 
  • Note if dilution of the sample significantly changes the microenvironment of the analyte sample relative to the conditions of the surrounding solvent. For instance, dilution of a reaction aliquot into a HPLC mobile phase may change the pH of the mobile phase as the analyzed sample travels through the column, resulting in changes in retention times or peak shapes. 
This, of course, from Practical Process Research and Development, pg. 156. 

Doing things the right way every time is difficult and annoying sometimes. That being said, it's the only way of generating a consistent body of data. It's kind of funny how (even at this level) you I need to be reminded of that. 

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

A NIH program director takes on chemical employment issues

From this week's issue of Chemical and Engineering News comes an article by Britt Erickson that talks with John Schwab, a retiring program director at NIGMS that's been a champion of organic synthesis. What does he have to say to the graduate students that he's helping to fund?
Another change is the employment outlook for organic chemistry graduates. “In the past, chemistry departments could turn out as many synthetic chemists as they wanted because pharma hired people who were trained very deeply, albeit fairly narrowly, in organic synthesis,” Schwab says. “But these days pharma isn’t doing much hiring in the U.S., if any. There are relatively few jobs now for people who are trained in this way.” 
Chemistry departments must keep pace with the changing workforce and train their students broadly, Schwab stresses. “I think we need to be very much involved with our graduate students and postdocs to understand what their career goals are and to help them be realistic about preparation for the careers that will be there,” he says. Departments should support alternative career paths such as journalism, law, or policy, he points out. “I think it is going to be very important that people be flexible.” 
For students still interested in pharma careers, Schwab notes, related jobs are moving to East Asia and South Asia. With that in mind, he says, “an understanding of foreign cultures and foreign languages would be useful” when job hunting.
It could be frustrating and even galling to hear such things about your industry. That being said, I'm really glad that someone that's relatively influential understands the difficulty that synthetic organic chemistry graduates in the United States are facing. I think the question that we're faced with is how many high-profile Big Pharma synthetic jobs will still be around in the next ten years and will there be a boom time again for organic chemists in industry. Right now, the answer doesn't look good.

I suspect that Schwab is, like the rest of us, casting about for an answer to these problems. His answer, like many in our field, is that chemists now need to be trained 'broadly.' I admit that I find this answer to be unsatisfactory, probably for emotional reasons than anything else. If there is a better time (and a longer one) in a chemist's lifespan to gain expertise in chemistry than in graduate school, I would like to know when that time is. Seems to me that postdoctoral training is an excellent time to gain broader experience in law, policy or journalism.

[By the way -- seriously? Journalism, law or policy? Two of these three fields are suffering terribly right now, and I don't think the world needs more Ph.D.-bearing policy analysts. Call me crazy.]

Perhaps it's stupid optimism (and self-interested, too!), but I suspect that some level of chemical employment will continue in the United States, and it won't be necessary to add functional Mandarin or Hindi to your candidacy exam. (Hopefully.)

But it's important, as Schwab says, to look at things realistically. While I might quibble with his answers, I see Dr. Schwab as a kindred spirit in that he's clearly attempting to wrestle with the question of chemical employment. Thanks to him for his service, and best wishes for his retirement and good luck to all of us.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Day off today

Willamette National Cemetery (Photo credit: oregonlive.com)
It's Memorial Day in the United States, so it's a holiday for the blog. Back tomorrow with more commentary on chemical employment. 

Friday, May 27, 2011

Salary talk: what is the salary range of a computational chemist?

If this is your attitude towards computers (like mine),
you shouldn't be a computational chemist.
Photo credit: liberaldoomsayer.blogspot.com
Thanks to yesterday's graph about salaries, I've gotten to thinking about salary levels of non-bench chemists, specifically computational chemists and the cheminformatics folks. What's their pay range in comparison to bench chemists? Are they paid higher or lower?

In the environments I've worked in, there are traditionally a lot fewer computational folks than there are traditional synthetic chemists. (With the advent of the designer/synthesizer model that Derek Lowe was posting about yesterday, of course, that might change.) If I were a manager, I might be tempted to pay a computational chemist slightly more than a bench to attract a really good experienced modeler. It's not going to cost you that much more, and their results are going to be driving your science (if you let it.) They also serve, those who stand and compute. 

On the other hand, there sure are a lot of computational chemists out there, and supply-and-demand does drive these discussions. 

In other salary talk =, how much of a salary discount should you expect for working for a start-up versus an established company? (Have you ever noticed that a lot of small companies will refer to themselves as a start-up during salary negotiations, even though they've been around for 10 years?) 

Readers, you know the answers. Please comment freely. 

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Chart of the week: US household income distribution and some chemist salaries

Screenshot from NPR's Planet Money
I'm a big fan of thinking about the distribution of income amongst US households. The Tax Policy Center has put together a data set that divides the different percentiles; NPR's Planet Money team has graphed it.

I thought I would annotate the distribution with a few Chemjobber-esque notations. GlassDoor is pretty helpful with the Pfizer salary estimates. Also, I used the ACS starting salary study from 2009.

*There was one bold Pfizer VP that put their salary on GlassDoor, so take that data point with a fairly large grain of salt. Also, I'm guessing there are significant bonuses at that level. 

Daily Pump Trap, 5/26/11 edition

Good morning! Between May 24 and May 25, there were 15 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 4 (27%) are academically connected.

Uhh...: Genentech/Roche has something to say to you:
Who you are: You’re someone who wants to influence your own development. You’re looking for a company where you have the opportunity to pursue your interests across functions and geographies and where a job title is not considered the final definition of who you are, but the starting point. 
Actually, 'you' in this case is a B.S./M.S. process chemist with a good bit of experience, to be hired in at the associate principal scientist level in South San Francisco. Also, 'you' may be a B.S./M.S. medicinal chemist to be hired in at the principal scientist level in Nutley, NJ.

And one more: SuperGen (try saying that without adding the mental exclamation point) is looking for a B.S. medicinal chemist with at least 5 years experience. They're located in Salt Lake City, Utah.

Coffee is for closers: BASF is looking for a B.S. chemist to become a salesperson to the pharmaceutical industry in North America. (30% travel minimum.)

Alpharetta, GA: Arch Chemicals is looking for an M.S./Ph.D. analytical chemist with specialization in mass spectrometry and separations science.

Winston-Salem, NC: Targacept desires a Ph.D. analytical chemist with 5 years experience in the pharmaceutical industry, with an eye towards method development and CMC support.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Can't help it

Original photo: JD Hancock
Seeing people make cracks about Vertex's success with Incivek and how it made them a tempting target for Pfizer (I doubt this is actually true) made me think of this old classic film.*

*Needless to say, Vertex is not Bambi (have ya read Billion Dollar Molecule?) and Pfizer isn't Godzilla. Right? Right?

Process Wednesday: a drum is a living thing

From my browsings of Organic Process Research and Development comes a story too freaky not to mention:
The material in question was in a poly drum that contained approximately 20 kg of the aniline as an oil. After storing the unused portion of the 4-trifluoromethylaniline for 6 months in a warehouse, the material was brought into the laboratory to be sampled for further pilot work. This particular storage facility did not have temperature control, and no information was received that this material required special storage conditions. Upon examination of the drum contents, the material had formed a solid crystalline mass. [snip -- description of warming the drum in a 50°C air drier] 
With this unexpected result it was decided to examine the contents of the drum by NMR. The entire drum was brought into the laboratory and was placed in a large, empty, stainless steel tub as an added safety precaution. With the bung loose the contents were allowed to equilibrate for 5 h at which point some liquid was removed for analysis, and the bung was tightened. Approximately 15-30 min after sealing the drum it ruptured near the bottom and a white gas exited the drum with tremendous force. This gas quickly filled the entire laboratory, and fortunately the only occupant of the laboratory at the time was able to exit from a rear fire door without being affected. When the gas evolution ceased after 15 min, an investigation of the incident was immediately initiated.
The authors went on to describe their analyses of the remaining material; they believed that the material is a trimerized form of the trifluoromethylaniline. The offgassing, they believed, was the release of HF. Needless to say, someone could have been seriously injured if they had been close enough to the drum. The article has a number of intelligent cautionary things to say about storing of trifluoromethylaniline and its potential reactivity.

Personally, I like drums. They're really useful things and they contain plenty of material (or compound or solvent) for the typical chemist. But I am always a little wary around them because they are so large; it's not like you can pick a drum up and throw it out into the parking lot (which is not recommended for any number of reasons). But something being larger than you is always something to be treated with more respect, in my novice mind.

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Are students willing to 'do what it takes' these days?

Do you know what love is, Kristel? It's finishing your degree,
and then working for 20k a year for a few years.
Photo credit: imdb.com
Thanks to a devoted reader, I'm treated to a CNN.com article about the difficulty in keeping STEM students in their STEM majors:
Undergraduates across the country are choosing to leave science, technology, engineering and math programs before they graduate with those degrees. Many students in those STEM fields struggle to complete their degrees in four years, or drop out, according to a 2010 University of California, Los Angeles, study. 
The study, conducted by UCLA's Higher Education Research Institute, found students in science, math and engineering take longer to complete their degrees than students who start out majoring in other fields. The study tracked thousands of students who entered college for the first time in 2004.
The article goes on to describe universities that have devoted some of their resources to changing their teaching style to attempt to stop some of this attrition. Good for them, I suppose.

But I'm amused to read a response in the comments (which, natural to any large website, is a treasure trove of headdesk), which I find typical of some people:
I have been a scientist in academia for almost 40 years and am at a top-ranked university.  From personal experience, most U.S. students who arrive on our doorstep wanting to major in STEM are not at the same level academically that they were 20 years ago and are not prepared to make the sacrifices it takes to succeed.  Foreign students are willing to work and sacrifice for their education, realizing that in these fields monetary success is often deferred.  Our youth in general are not trained to look at the long term but instead want 70K jobs when they graduate with a B.S.
I think it's silly to make the assertion that the kidz are not willing to defer gratification -- that's why they're in school, right? Because if it's Money Now they're after, waiting tables or selling mortgages insurance might be a better route. I think it is true that some students are looking hard at whether their time spent in school will lead them to a modicum of return; their expected return, I suppose, might be higher than some foreign students.

Ultimately, I suspect that it's true -- some people aren't willing to defer financial gratification. For them, STEM majors aren't a good idea (and they don't typically end up there to begin with.) But I suspect that many students are looking long and hard to see if their deferred gratification is actually that -- and finding out that the answer might be no.

Daily Pump Trap, 5/24/11 edition

Good morning! Between May 19 and May 23, there were 23 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 5 (22%) are academically connected and 1 (4%) is from our friends at Kelly Scientific Resources.

RTP!: DuPont weighs in with another Ph.D. chemist position, this time for a microelectronics research investigator. Inorganic background preferred, with "experience in crystalline Si cell production processes or materials."

Can't find what you want?: ATL International has been looking for nuclear forensic chemists for a while; in this position, you will "establish and maintain a quality assurance management system for laboratory operations that supports the requirements of an interagency national technical nuclear forensics program." Mass spec and other radiochemistry technique experience is desired. They're talking about 2000 (I'm guessing) qualified candidates here -- I wonder what's the best way to reach them?

Tamaqua, PA: Silberline Manufacturing Company is looking for a research scientist to perform work on pigments. You will be working on "Organic and Inorganic synthesis of functional adducts" and "Surface Chemistry of aluminum, glass, and other substrates to modify the color and/or rheological behavior of the materials". There's a nice little blurb about what you'll be responsible for, too: "Those hired will quickly take on responsibility for projects and will evolve to initiating and carrying out projects independently. We are looking for people who enjoy hands-on laboratory experimentation, teamwork, and also possess an entrepreneurial mindset." Good luck!

Zeroes!: Eastman Chemical Company in Kingsport, TN is looking for a Ph.D. chemist to be a process development researcher; 0-5 years experience is desired, along with a Ph.D. in organic chemistry. Gee -- I wonder if there are any of those?

Workin' for the man: FDA has come out with four postdoctoral positions in analytical chemistry in St. Louis, MO. Enjoy!

Hello, again: Our friends at Halcyon Molecular are back, looking for a M.S./Ph.D. chemist with experience in preparatory-scale chromatography; 5 years experience is desired. 

Monday, May 23, 2011

Not all Ph.D. chemists are managers, nor want to be

From this week's Chemical and Engineering News, a vaguely irritating letter:
While working toward a Ph.D. in physical chemistry, I noticed that many Ph.D.s in industry eventually moved out of the lab and into management (and perhaps picked up an M.B.A. along the way), hoping never to soil their hands with research again. Also, conversations with industry recruiters usually got around to the career ladder, with implications that after a few years one would move up and out of the lab. 
My love for the lab bench was the reason I chose a chemistry career to begin with, so this trend of moving from Ph.D. to off the lab bench was not for me. I decided to finish my studies with an M.S. degree. After five years, I still wound up managing a quality-control lab as chief chemist at an industrial plant, but I made sure to always have some bench time. 
Sure, it would have been nice to have a Dr. in front of my name when sending out Christmas cards, but if that meant not being able to train young chemical technicians in the lab and solve those chemical mysteries, then it would not be worth it. After a few downsizings, I wound up again running a small lab with one or two young chem techs, solving problems and enjoying getting my hands dirty at the lab bench. Too many Ph.D.s? Maybe, maybe not. I think one should have an idea of what they want to do with the degree that they are pursuing and not just get the degree and see what happens. 
Peter Doorley
Memphis
With all due respect to Mr. Doorley, some of this thinking is quite unfair. I don't know about other Ph.D. chemists, but I completed my degree because I wanted to finish something (for once in my life) and contribute to the chemical sciences, as opposed to finishing my degree so that I could someday sit in front of a computer (which seems to be the fate of the desk-bound chemist these days.)* Mr. Doorley also does not allow for the "up-or-out" mechanism at work for many Ph.D. chemists where they are expected to slowly move into leadership positions (whether they deserve them or not.)

It is also worth noting that training young chemists and solving chemical problems is the best part of being a senior chemist (of any education level.) While I am sure that there are those chemists who enjoy their time sitting in meetings and plotting the fates of many, I believe that there are many, many Ph.D. chemists who far prefer to influence younger generations and to solve key chemistry issues.

All of this to say that Mr. Doorley paints with a broad brush, and I feel unfairly besplattered.

*I'm going to be vaguely cynical here and make note that "I made sure to always have some bench time" is classic boss-speak for spending 2 hours in the lab performing a menial task that takes 30 minutes, all the while bothering your minions asking "Where are the pipettes?" and "Who moved my Gewurtztraminer apparatus?".