Friday, February 11, 2011

By request




N.B. I've never played MtG*, so I don't know if I've done some awful faux pas here.

Card is parody of the "Raging Pessimist" card designed by David Tidd and Mark Tidd.

*Or any other role-playing game, for that matter.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Q&A with Bethany Halford Friday

Tomorrow, I'm posting an e-mail interview with Bethany Halford, author of the "Doctoral Dilemma" article in C&EN about the "too many Ph.D.s problem." I'm excited that Dr. Halford has agreed to make an occasional appearance to respond to comments as well, so that will be great. See you there tomorrow.

Chart of the week: taking yourself out of the labor force

Credit: Mike Konczal, Rortybomb.
Above is one of the more frightening graphs of the recession from Mike Konczal of the progressive Rortybomb econoblog. How are people leaving the ranks of the unemployed? Well, a higher percentage of the unemployed are simply leaving the workforce, as opposed to actually finding a new position.

Consider a hypothetical process chemist in her late-50's. Assuming that the family finances are in relatively good shape, will she go out and attempt to find a new position or simply retire a little earlier? A lot more people are choosing the latter option.

Best wishes to all of us.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/10/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 8 and February 9, there were 55 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 4 (7%) were academically connected; 1 (2%) position is from Kelly Scientific Resources.

Merck (cont.): I don't know who's asleep at the switch, but someone is. 41 (75%) of the newly posted positions were with Merck. While there were some actual chemistry or science-related positions (such as a senior DMPK scientist), there were more positions for utility engineers, administrative associates and copy editors.

Oh, by the way, hepatitis is spelled with an "a" as opposed to an 'i', and commercialization has 2 'a's.

More jobs from the Company: CIA is searching for B.S./M.S. chemists (at minimum) for their Weapons Intelligence, Nonproliferation, and Arms Control Center (WINPAC). "WINPAC seeks engineers and scientists to analyze challenging national security issues such as foreign weapons development, weapons proliferation, and information warfare and emerging technologies." Good luck figuring out what's going on in Elbonia.

San Jose: Cheil Industries is looking for a M.S./Ph.D. chemist that must have experience in dye chemical/chromophore synthesis. Good luck!

A broader look: Monster.com, Careerbuilder.com and Indeed.com show (respectively) 282, 682 and 4,749 positions for the search term "chemist."

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

How difficult is it to become a small college professor?

Dr. Jones, how hard was it
to get your position?
Photo credit: indy4.info
A reader writes in to ask:
[Someone I know] says that the paltry job market doesn't apply to chemistry professor positions at D3 schools* (where you'd only have to teach, no research).  I have a hard time finding this to be true.  What do you think?
*I assume this is referring to NCAA Division III, i.e. smallish institutions.
I think that person is wrong, but I have no data. Certainly, the recent article in C&EN remarks on the tough competition to get one of those tenure-track professor positions at a liberal arts college. I believe that if you're in a field where there's a lot of people (e.g. organic chemistry), getting a TT position at a small school is pretty much equally competitive as a larger school.

I suspect that as you get into the smaller and smaller schools and community colleges, competition and the quality of CV starts to drift downwards, but these are presumably less desirable positions (from a status perspective.) The pay starts to get a lot lower, too.

There are also demographic trends to be considered -- are there enough 18 year olds coming in future generations to cover the expansion in colleges and universities we've seen in the last 20 years? I doubt it, but again, I have no data.

Readers, what say you? Is my reader's acquaintance incorrect? Anyone been out there on the small college faculty job search? What are you seeing?

55mm Whatman filter paper

Some small useful things (links) that I like:

Process Wednesday: current Good Manufacturing Practice

Something that I keep hearing about in the manufacture of pharmaceutical products is "cGMP", which stands for "current Good Manufacturing Practice". I'll be completely honest and say that I don't really quite understand what it really encompasses and what is different about a cGMP facility and a non-GMP facility (other than a lot less paperwork, I suppose.) It's worth considering the FDA's comments on GMP: "The regulations in this part [CJ: this is from the CFR] contain the minimum current good manufacturing practice for preparation of drug products for administration to humans or animals."

Wikipedia tells me that cGMP are "guidelines that outline the aspects of production and testing that can impact the quality of a product." It is my understanding that cGMP typically tells an drug manufacturer "what" must be done, as opposed to "how" it should be done. In the GMP Wikipedia article, there is also a list of the different components of a GMP program:
  • Manufacturing processes are clearly defined and controlled. All critical processes are validated to ensure consistency and compliance with specifications.
  • Manufacturing processes are controlled, and any changes to the process are evaluated. Changes that have an impact on the quality of the drug are validated as necessary.
  • Instructions and procedures are written in clear and unambiguous language.
  • Operators are trained to carry out and document procedures.
  • Records are made, manually or by instruments, during manufacture that demonstrate that all the steps required by the defined procedures and instructions were in fact taken and that the quantity and quality of the drug was as expected. Deviations are investigated and documented.
  • Records of manufacture (including distribution) that enable the complete history of a batch to be traced are retained in a comprehensible and accessible form.
  • The distribution of the drugs minimizes any risk to their quality.
  • A system is available for recalling any batch of drug from sale or supply.
  • Complaints about marketed drugs are examined, the causes of quality defects are investigated, and appropriate measures are taken with respect to the defective drugs and to prevent recurrence.
When I read this (mind-boggling) list of criteria, I begin to see the core of cGMP, which is that pharmaceutical manufacturing needs to be consistent and documented. When I think about how it might be applied to a single synthetic step, I think it means that chemistry needs to be well-documented, very, very robust and the product/impurity profile should not change over time.* Hard to imagine that it would be otherwise, but I suppose that there's a whole backstory of awful mistakes that led the industry and the government to this point.

Readers, what am I missing? If you were to explain cGMP to a 1st year graduate student, how would you do it?

*Dude, it's so clear I don't know what I'm talking about here.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

The uses of chemical jargon

We're going to hook this thing up to your NMR -- do you mind?
Photo credit: Techeblog.com
Excimer's posting of a "turboencabulator" video by Chrysler was pretty priceless. For a taste, see below:
The line-up consisted simply of six hydrocoptic marzul vanes so fitted to the ambaphascient lunar wain shaft that side fumbling was effectively prevented. The main winding was of the normal lotus-odeltoid type placed in panendurmic semi-bulloid slots of the stator. Every seventh conductor being connected by a non-reversible tremmy pipe to the differential girdle spring on the up-end of the grammeters. (script from Wikipedia)
It's always interesting to me how jargon gets used. I've found that it's used as a credential; if I meet someone and they talk like a chemist (e.g. they use "diastereotopic" or "phthalate" correctly and without fumbling the pronunciation), I'm more likely to believe what they say. Jargon cannot take the place of an education, but it can be used as a signaling device.

Sometimes, it's used to obfuscate. If you tell your sales guy that "we're experiencing a variety of polymorphs in our recrystallization experiments", it sounds a lot better than "our purification isn't working." While I think a smart customer and an intelligent salesperson will know what you're doing, the first statement provides a level of specificity that suggests "hey, these people know what's going wrong and therefore, they're more likely to fix the problem." All of this, of course, assumes that you actually have multiple polymorphs in your recrystallization -- if you actually don't and you say that, well, you're lying.

I think the right way to use jargon as a tool for exactness; it can shorten conversations ("NMR" and "TLC" are really helpful abbreviations) and can help you say exactly what you want to say, when you want to say it. Like any tool, there's a time and a place for each use, even when it's connected by a non-reversible tremmy pipe.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/8/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 3 and February 7, there were 83 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 21 (25%) are academically connected.

Hmmmm: Merck, why do you do this to us? Of the posted positions, 45 of them are from Merck. Of these, relatively few of them are actual chemistry position. Sure, they're looking for a senior research chemist (materials characterization) and a senior analytical chemist, but they're also looking for a customer solutions intern, an administrative assistant and a payroll analyst. This is a little bit frustrating.

On the other hand: Clorox is looking for 2 scientists: a senior product developer at the Clorox company and an associate research fellow at Brita (an expert on water sciences is desired there.) Both are Ph.D. preferred positions. Hey, Merck, that's how you use ACS Careers as a resource.

Interesting...: The Population Council is looking for a Ph.D. scientist to develop pre-clinical formulations for contraceptives. Formulation experience desired.

No recalls here: Finally, the Toyota Institute is looking for 3 contract battery research scientists; M.S. and above is the desired educational level, as well as "[r]esearch experience related to at least one of following technical fields; electrochemistry, solid state chemistry, inorganic synthesis, or analytical chemistry."

Monday, February 7, 2011

Nice economy you've got there -- 'twould be a shame if something were to happen to it...

Now here's a tactic unemployed chemists should adopt -- a mild threat disguised as an appeal for funding. Regarding the impending shutdown of the Tevatron* that employs over 1,000 physicists (hat tip Planet Money):
To the Editor: 
Re “The Tevatron” (editorial, Jan. 22): 
It is not only sad that such a productive atom smasher as the Tevatron in Illinois will be shut down but it may also not be wise. When, in 1993, Congress shut off funds for the superconducting supercollider being built underground in Texas, many of the newly unemployed physicists found jobs on Wall Street. Wouldn’t you rather have the nation’s physicists smashing protons than designing and smashing collateralized debt obligations? 
Jay M. Pasachoff
Naomi Pasachoff
Pasadena, Calif., Jan. 22, 2011 
The writers are, respectively, a visiting scientist at Caltech and a research associate at Williams College.
I can only imagine the letter to the editor now. "It is not only sad that the Pfizer Sandwich site in the UK may be shut down, but it may also not be wise. Many foreign regimes would pay healthy sums to unemployed industrial chemists to develop processes for certain dual-use industrial chemicals. Wouldn't you rather have the nation's chemists synthesizing pharmaceutical compounds than designing and deploying weapons of mass destruction?"**

* Why doesn't DOE build massive chemistry experiments for the employment of chemists? I'm sure origin-of-life chemistry could use a little boost, to name a random field.
**A note to any US/UK intelligence assets reading this blog: this is satire. 

Friday, February 4, 2011

BREAKING: Unemployment down to 9.0%, U6 at 16.1%

Fresh electrons from the Bureau of Labor Statistics: the national unemployment rate for January is 9.0% (down from December's 9.4%), while the broader U6 measurement of unemployment is 16.1% (down from December's 16.7%). We've got a long way to go, but this is moving in the right direction for now.

UPDATE: So the general consensus seems to be that this is bad news. Sigh.

Heaven and Hell

In Heaven's chemistry lab...

1. The solvent bottles refill themselves.
2. Your coworkers clean up after themselves and offer to clean your things, too.
3. The HPLCs are always working, and the lines are clog free.
4. There are no bump bulbs on the rotovaps, because there is no bumping.
5. Everyone has their own stool, and no one's ever stealing yours.
6. Columns packing doesn't require tapping or waiting and elute cleanly.
7. You can't overshoot a titration.
8. There's always plenty of buffer solution, and you never have to make more.
9. Glassware puts itself back in the drawer.
10. The stopcocks on separatory funnels are easy to turn and don't ever fill up with salts.
11. There is no queue for the NMR.

In Hell's chemistry lab:

1. There is no solvent, anywhere, not even in your labmate's bench. You fill your flask straight from the drum.
2. Running a reaction always requires reaching into the base bath for glassware.
3. There's one HPLC and the line goes around the block.
4. You have to keep your thumb on the rotovap stopcock to hold vacuum.
5. You stand and you stand and you stand.
6. Columns? What columns? It's prep TLC, all day, all night. Scrape, scrape, scrape
7. There is no endpoint for titrations.
8. All your labmates have bad breath and like to stand really, really close to you. Danger close, even.
9. Every single round bottom has a nervous-making star crack.
10. All you have is a 25 mL sep funnel with a 29/42 neck. Good luck finding a stopper.

Thanks to Leigh for the inspiration.

C&EN needs a new JAEP

As you may have seen, C&EN is looking for a new Electron Pusher. See Rachel Pepling's post below:
I’m looking for someone (perhaps a student or a poor unemployed soul or a poor employed discontented soul with a boss who doesn’t read blogs) who isn’t quite convinced that the traditional academic or industry route is the one for her or him to take and who has an entertaining writing voice. Profiles of the nontraditional careers that pop up as part of your search will be a big part of JAEP, but so are the more reflective, personal ones (think Leigh’s rejection post).

In exchange, I can offer a monthly pittance and access to some great mentors.

If you’re interested in the gig or in guestposting during this interim period, leave a comment or email me at r_pepling at acs dot org.
So if you're interested in writing, e-mail Rachel and give it a shot. This stuff (chemistry blogging) is pretty fun.

Spooky learning at a distance

The other day, I was wandering around the internet, and I came across the University of Florida's pharmaceutical chemistry online master's program. From the associated literature:
Enroll in a Master's of Science Degree in Pharmaceutical Chemistry from the University of Florida, College of Pharmacy! Join a growing number of scientists who are receiving their graduate science degrees from the University of Florida's prestigious online programs.

Pharmaceutical Chemistry - Educated Inspiration

• Master a challenging field of science
• Prepare for or enhance a career in pharmaceutical innovation and regulation
• Contribute to life saving remedies and enhance the speed of delivery of new medications
• Translate your personal experiences to benefit others
What to say about this? I am sure that someday, the University of Florida will have an online master's program that's really worthy of spending serious money on. But for now, a master's degree in chemistry at most United States universities is free. They pay you, you don't pay them. While there are all sorts of things to be said about the hooks in the system, the chance to walk away from school free of student loans is valuable.

Also, they're really overselling the employability of this degree. Would any hiring manager look at this degree as being equivalent to one having been done in the traditional fashion at Florida State or UGA or any equivalent public university? I doubt it.

Readers, I think I'm right, but maybe I'm wrong. What do you think?

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Oh, THIS is a good idea

Yeah, I'll get right on that. (Click)
Photo credit: abagond.wordpress.com
In the comments to Derek Lowe's two threads on the further adventures of the HR Angel of Death at Pfizer, there was this little gem:
At Cambridge North we were told today that there wont be any "wet chemistry" going forward. The only chemists at the site will be what are known around here as "designers" for Inflammation/Immunology, CVMED and Neuroscience. The later two will be moved from Groton to Cambridge. Get rid of the hoods (and of course the chemists) and move in the cubicles! This will most definitely increase productivity and save the company.
Further explanation from another commenter:
Pfizer recently went to a model that separated out the medicinal chemists into two "bins" - designers and synthetic chemists. These are not computational chemists or modelers (by and large) they are the traditional medicinal chemists. The "designers" are now just charged with designing compounds for their projects (just like a traditional medicinal chemist would be expected to do) - but they do not then go make the compounds. They hand the "designs" off to the synthetic chemists to make. One SVP from Pfizer "tried" to explain this model and how it made sense because not everyone wants to design and some just want to be synthetic chemists and work at the hood (Ph.D. level). I think everyone in the room during this explanation could see the writing on the wall that the synthetic chemists had a very short shelf life and would be out-sourced very quickly. There was also talk about reward systems for both, yada, yada, yada.
In a nutshell, new hires (if there were any) would come in at the synthetic chemist level and would then have to work up to the designer level (if they so chose). This clearly was a model based upon outsourcing the synthetic portion of the equation - although based on yesterday's news it may not matter at all if you work for Pfizer.
Has anyone at Pfizer ever played telephone? Physically separating the 'designers' and the 'chemists' by 108 miles is lunacy; sometimes it's occasionally difficult to communicate between two chemists separated by 30 feet (distance from office to lab.) Assuming this is actually happening, this is proof that Pfizer senior management has completely lost their marbles and are just rearranging deck chairs.

Once again, I am reminded of the many, many comments that people have made about what makes a successful drug discovery team (not that I've ever truly been part of one): lots of communication and collaboration (and downtime out-of-meeting talks) between the relevant scientists, both chemists and biologists. I am curious when larger pharma companies will relearn these truths.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/3/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 1st and February 2nd, there were ~450 (not a typo) new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, not very many were academic positions (????%).

Wha happened??: Merck decided that ACS Careers was a great place to look for chemists. There are a couple of chemistry positions buried in here; Merck also decided that ACS Careers was a great place to look for maintenance mechanics, manufacturing supervisors, a Russian national field force manager and a payroll supervisor. I am not kidding. It appears to me that Merck posted close to 443 positions, approximately 50% of which have to do with science and about 10 of which have to do with chemistry.

There are so many positions that they're not even coded into the rest of the search engine yet, which is really annoying. If you ask it to search for "Merck and Co" positions, it will tell you that there aren't any. Awesome.

I was under the impression that I could chew through these this morning (it pegged the heck out of my RSS reader, too, which is impressive), but it'll have to wait for tonight. Sorry, folks.

UPDATE: Not much help, but this is something I learned last night. There are (again, not kidding) 110 ophthamology sales positions all across the country (100 sales reps, 10 or so team leaders.)

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

My snow day story that involves fire

So I can't think of anything really truly funny to post, so here's my snow day story (that doesn't involve any snow):

So we're in San Diego, it's fall of 2007. The Santa Ana winds are kicking up and they're bringing one terrible awful firestorm down on San Diego County. Sunday night of that week, the hotels on Hotel Circle are filling up with people from Poway and points east. Sometime on Sunday night or Monday morning, they evacuate darn near everyone in the northern part of San Diego County.

So I roll into work (I'm a postdoc) on Monday morning and there's no one there. It's dead silent. The dry ice guy (who I almost never talk to, because he's all iPodded up) and I chat, and he's sayin' "Dude, I'm outta here and heading home after this delivery." After a while, I decide, you know what? Nobody's here, it smells like smoke in the lab, I'm heading home. Later that day, I call the main line at work, and they tell me that everything's closed for the day. The day after, they announce that because of the lack of emergency resources (all the fire guys are in east county), there will be NO bench chemistry and work is closed for the week.

Here's my thinking: "Man, I'm going to miss a whole week of bench time. You know what? I'll bet those boys and girls down at TSRI are still workin' in the lab." I drive to work that Tuesday, pick up my books, head home and start reading.

Later, I have a chance to interact with a postdoc from TSRI. "Hey, did you guys work during the fires?", I ask. The postdoc nods. 

Process Wednesday: tossing aqueous layers STILL a bad idea

From our friend Neal Anderson and his book:
Understand the partitioning of the desired product in each phase during every stage of the extraction process. Collect each "spent" phase, label the container, and store until it is clear that the extract can be discarded without losing yield or valuable process history that could be collected by analyzing the extract. 
You know, this is pretty good advice, especially during that first large-scale extraction. At the same time, it can start to clutter up the lab if there's a bunch of work going on. Nonetheless, good advice. (P.S. That "label the container" part is really important, too.)  

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

How important is networking? How do you get good at it?

A recent post by Daniel Levy brings up the topic of networking, especially regarding job-hunting:
While the preceding paragraphs emphasized the value of a strong education, they did not focus on skills important to finding and maintaining employment. Among the most important is networking. Sure, while social groups such as Facebook, Linked-in and Twitter can provide some resources, the greatest networking activities involve face-to-face introductions/conversations. These must also be accompanied by diligent follow-up...

[snip] In closing, most of one's success will always depend upon a strong knowledge and skill base.  However, There is always a component that directly relates to who one knows and what opportunities are available at any given time.  The value of networking will not always be immediately recognized - but when it pays off, the dividends are usually significant.
This reminded me of a couple of posts by Lisa Balbes over at the ACS Careers blog, which lay out what that "diligent follow-up" might look like. To wit:
One way to test this is by looking at your list of connections, and asking yourself “Would this person take my phone call?” An even better question – “If I lost my job and called this person, would they merely sympathize, or would they go out of their way to look for leads and opportunities that matched my background and professional goals?

To turn it around, how many of the people in your professional network have you talked to lately? How many have you done a favor for, or passed along a tidbit that you thought might help them out? How many do make contact with on a regular basis? Or do you look your list of connections and try to remember where you met them, and why you wanted to connect in the first place? [snip]

For people you haven’t talked to in awhile, make contact. Send an email, write a card, or pick up the phone.
As I am relatively early in my career, I'm not quite sure what "good networking" looks like. At the same time, it seems to look like being a friendly, helpful person who remembers people and cares about them. I think the internet makes that sort of thing relatively simple; e-mails and LinkedIn notes aren't too fraught with nervousness, even if you're the world's most awkward, introverted person on the phone or face-to-face. As Levy notes, I'm hesitant to say that it's the cure-all for a tough time looking for work, but it can help.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/1/11 edition

Good morning! Between January 27 and January 31, there have been 48 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of those, 18 (38%) are academically connected and 3 (6%) are from Kelly Scientific Resources.

Well, that sounds interesting: BASF is looking for a Ph.D. in engineering or chemistry (1-3 years experience) that has experience with a "Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP) reactor"; you'll be using it in conjunction with heterogenous catalysts.

Resins: TenCate Advanced Composites USA is looking for a B.S. chemist (advanced degree desired) with 3+ years experience with thermosetting resins.

QC: Genentech's campus in South San Francisco is searching for a Ph.D. analytical chemist with 5-7 years experience with biotechnology quality control; looks like you'll be part of their corporate-wide QC team.

Hello, biotech!: Intrexon is a company that uses "modular DNA control systems to enhance capabilities, improve safety and lower cost in human therapeutics, protein production, industrial enzymes and agbio." They're looking for a 3 synthetic chemistry positions, one at each level of education. Looks like at least one of them is in the production of combinatorial arrays (someone still does that?!?)

The party people!: Chemical Abstracts Services is searching for a B.S. chemist with Japanese language expertise for their editorial/database creation team. Sounds interesting, especially if you like Big Ten college football.