Friday, February 25, 2011

Factlets from yesterday's ACS Webinar -- March 2010 ACS unemployment: 3.8%, new grads getting hammered

Yesterday's ACS Webinar on chemistry employment and unemployment featured ACS's own Gareth Edwards (who directs the ACS Salary Survey) and 2 economists from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Roger Moncarz and Brian Roberts. You can see all the slides here.

This blogpost will mostly focus on the data from the 2010 ACS Salary Survey, as the BLS outlook is something that we've covered on this blog (that there's really slow job growth projected for this industry, in comparison to materials science.)

Overall unemployment: as of March 2010, the unemployment rate is 3.8% for ACS members, which is slightly lower from the 2009 number of 3.9%. As Mr. Edwards points out, these are the two highest numbers that ACS has recorded since the beginnings of the survey in 1972.

Human capital destruction: The mean jobless period for ACS members is 11 months, with the median at 9 months. As the unemployed are keenly aware, it is commonly believed that skill set erosion starts in at 3 to 6 months. Mr. Edwards suggests that the relative fall in unemployment is probably due to a combination of people leaving the workforce, combined with chemists taking jobs that are below their skill set ("underemployment").

Experience is winning: One of the key messages of the webinar was that contrary to conventional wisdom, it is younger and less-educated cohorts, not older ones, that are experiencing the most difficulty in finding positions in chemistry. The respective unemployment rates for B.S., M.S. and Ph.D. chemists is 5.1%, 4.8 and 3.2%.

Wow: The final, staggering statistic from the webinar was the unemployment rates for new B.S. chemistry graduates: 9.4% in 2008, 15.9% in 2009. By comparison, the New York Times reported that the BLS unemployment rate for college graduates under 25 was 8% in April 2010.

Even more good news: The final quote from the seminar: "The loss of jobs may be a permanent adjustment without the typical recovery of other recessions."

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Chart of the week: The housing market and the labor mobility of chemists

It's not talked about a lot, but I'll bet there were a lot of pharma/biotech chemists affected by the housing market. Here's the latest Case-Shiller measurement of various housing markets across the country, courtesy of the Calculated Risk blog:

Chart credit: Calculated Risk.
You'll note, of course, that 3 of the 5 (?) major pharma/biotech hubs (SF, SD and Boston) have sustained fairly drastic hits to their prices: 38%, 37% and 15% drops (respectively.)

It seems obvious to me that there are a significant (but unmeasured!) number of scientists who are underwater on their homes and cannot participate in the national labor market. Granted, they might not want to move, but unless their new company in Boston can help them out, a Bay Area chemist might just choose to stay a Bay Area chemist.

It also seems obvious to me that this is bad: labor mobility is one of the great attributes of the American economy. If the government wanted to do something useful, aiding people who want to get out from under their home and move somewhere else for a job would seem like a good start.*

*Look, I know this is going to help out some people who were stupid with their money, but that's the price of getting things going again. 

The ChemWiki project needs you!

Got time? Want to work on something useful? Professor Delmar Larsen of UC Davis' ChemWiki project is looking for a few good editors. For details, see below:
The aim of the ChemWiki is to develop and disseminate a virtual customizable textbook that will substitute for paper textbooks in multiple chemistry courses at multiple post-secondary institutions across the nation. Textbook costs are a major factor in pursuing higher education and efforts to control/minimize such costs for a majority of students are important at essentially every institution in the country. The ChemWiki project will reduce out of pocket costs for education for undergraduate students, which is a common concern across the higher education spectrum, especially for low-income students.
I'm quite fond of (because I contributed to) the ChemWiki's techniques section, when Kyle Finchsigmate's lab ChemWiki was all the rage.

Go to it, folks!

Daily Pump Trap: 2/24/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 22 and 23, there were 62 new positions posted on the ACS Careers database. Of these, 5 (8%) are academically connected.

Merrrrrrrrrrck!: Of these 62 positions, 45 (73%) of them are from Merck and Co. Care to guess how many are vaguely science-related? Probably about half. Sure, they might want you to be a Ph.D. analytical chemist, but they're just as likely to ask you to be a global exhibit manager or an audit manager.

CMC: Aveo Pharmaceuticals is looking for a Ph.D. chemist with 8+ years in the pharmaceutical industry to be their CMC drug manager; scale-up experience with small molecules and biomolecules is desired.

Tecan? Tecan!: Cubist is looking for a B.S./M.S. chemist to be their compound management specialist.

Secret: The Aerospace Corporation has posted two positions in polymer chemistry (one B.S., one Ph.D.) for the southern California area.

HomeSec: Oak Ridge Associated Universities are looking for postdocs for their Transportation Security Laboratory to work on explosive detection research. DSC and TGA experience desired. The salary is awwwfully nice at 70k. 

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The dumbest thing I ever did in the lab, #642

Gather around and listen to a little story about Uncle CJ and his days in grad school:
Picture this, Sicily! 1932! So there we were in the lab and there was this summer student. Super smart, not super experienced and she's trying to get a reaction to work. It used to work, it works with the grad student she works with and now, of course, it's not working. She's close to tears, sad that she's going to disappoint her out-of-town grad student mentor (who's really nice and wouldn't be too disappointed, let's be clear) and is generally frustrated at her sudden Sidam touch.

So my buddy and I were listening to her sadness and one of us hit on a way of putting a smile on this undergrad's face. One of us squirts a healthy bit of acetone on the lab floor, the other lights it on fire with a spark striker. We then squirt circles of flaming acetone with the squirt bottle and sing "Ring of Fire". Instant happy summer student, no tears. 
Look, kids, DO NOT GO AND DO THIS. IT WAS DUMB. It could have ended in tragedy, with the squirt bottle holder seriously injured.

Lesson: a grad student will do anything, anything to avoid tears from their subordinates.

Process Wednesday: a little process history

From Anderson et al.'s recent review* in Organic Process Research and Development, a brief mention of the beginnings of process chemistry:
...Later, validation was required for processes to prepare APIs and intermediates, by recording compliance of batch operating parameters within specified limits and by subjecting the batch outputs to various pass/fail analyses by Quality Control departments operating independently of their manufacturing counterparts.

Before the 1970s most pharmaceutical companies paid relatively little attention to efficient process development. Scaleups from the laboratory were often based on lore, with experiences sometimes communicated only verbally. Through reactions on a larger scale, often kilograms, the different mass transfer and heat transfer rates exposed limits underlying seemingly straightforward operations.
Wow, really? Some of this is easily imaginable, especially the first part. So far as I understand, the old-school assembly line model is at work here: you make a bunch of widgets, test them all and throw out the bad ones. It's not surprising to imagine that manufacturing chemistry worked the same way and that data on what's working (and what's not) was probably not being passed back to the plant. (I wonder, were Deming and his friends ever involved in process/manufacturing chemistry?)

The second portion of the quote is harder to imagine today -- imagine not requiring some sort of written procedure or protocol for scaleup! The thought of allowing verbal lore to guide quite detailed and expensive scale-ups is amusing in hindsight. I'll bet there were a lot of messy cleanups to be had back then.

*Anderson, N.G.; Burdick, D.C.; Reeve, M.M. "Current Practices of Process Validation for Drug Substances and Intermediates." Org. Process. Res. Dev. 2011, 15, 162-172.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

The Big Picture: ...and the hits just keep on comin'

Over at Chemicals and the Economy, Paul Hodges lays it down not-so-gently, suggesting that high oil prices ($3.15 for gasoline where I am) are affecting Americans right in the pocketbook (and chemists in the chemical industry):
Graph credit: Paul Hodges, Chemicals and the Economy

"Consumers have no real choice about their spend on gasoline and energy bills. And its only after these have been paid, that they decide whether they can afford the discretionary spending that drives chemical and polymer sales.

Of course, sentiment indicators, even well-established ones like this from the University of Michigan can be wrong. But it just adds to the blog's sense of uncertainty about what is really happening to end-user demand, and to inventories down the value chain."
And at Calculated Risk, some economists (Justin Weidner and John Williams) from the San Francisco Federal Reserve talk about the "new normal" in unemployment rates:
A second explanation is that the degree of mismatch between job seekers and potential employers has increased. The construction, finance, and real estate sectors have shrunk after the bursting of the housing bubble and the subsequent financial crisis. The skills of workers who used to be employed in those sectors may not be easily transferable to growing sectors such as education and health care (see Rissman 2009 and Barnichon et al. 2010). Similarly, the housing bust has left millions of homeowners underwater on their mortgages, which locks them into their homes and may make it more difficult for them to move to higher growth areas. These sectoral and geographic mismatches between workers and job openings may be making it harder for employers to fill vacancies. [snip]

Mounting evidence suggests that structural factors may have increased the “normal” rate of unemployment to about 6.7%. Much of this increase is likely to be temporary. In particular, the extension of unemployment benefits probably accounts for about half of the increase. But, even with a 6.7% natural rate, current and forecasted levels of unemployment imply that significant labor market slack will persist for several years. It is important to stress that each of the methods used to estimate the natural rate is subject to considerable error, especially given the limited experience of very high unemployment in the post-World War II U.S. economy.
[CJ here again.] It's a weird couple of things to link together, but here goes my thoughts:
  • Hodges' notes on the high price of oil and gasoline do not bode well for chemists in the consumer products world. If consumers are spending on heat and gas, they're not buying as much toothpaste and shampoo. For that matter, high oil and gas prices do not bode well for the health care dollar, either.
  • At the same time, I am curious about the employment prospects for oil and gas chemists; I suspect that they are close to a local maxima.
  • Weidner and Williams suggest a few sectors that are doing poorly, employment-wise: construction, finance and real estate. No surprise there. They suggest 2 sectors doing well: education and health care. In my opinion, both of these 2 sectors are primed for a bubble.
  • That said, I suspect that chemists looking to move are better positioned (re: skill set) than folks in those 3 hurting sectors.
  • It will still be a few years until the "new normal" arrives. And when it does, it is unclear what it will look like.

Chemical engineers needed in Jacksonville, Florida

I have been contacted by a recruiter for some B.S./M.S. chemical engineering positions in Jacksonville, Florida. If interested, contact Lisa Crawford at lcrawford -at- appleone/dot/com.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/22/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 17 and February 21, there were 26 new positions posted on the ACS Careers database. Of these, 6 (23%) are academically connected.

Opportunities in Cambridge: E-Ink leads the way this week with a posting of 5 positions, including one for a B.S. chemist with 0-5 years experience in hydrocarbon-based ink formulations. In my opinion, this sort of thing is becoming bigger and bigger in our world; great opportunity to get in on the ground floor.

Hard hat: Arkema is searching for a plant manager; degree in engineering and a MBA are desired. "Experience in fabrication or plastic extrusion or an analogous business is required." Well, that knocks me out. Sigh.

Now here's something: The Journal of Medicinal Chemistry and ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters are looking for a managing editor; a Ph.D. in chemistry/biology is desired. Experience in technical publishing is desired, but does not appear to be necessary. "The Managing Editor of the publication is responsible for the day-to-day management of Journal of Medicinal Chemistry and ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters and ensures that the publications are produced on time, on budget, and with appropriate levels of quality."

In my opinion, this is a plum position for the right mid-career pharma professional. Good luck.

And here's another one!: The Michael J. Fox Foundation is looking for a Ph.D. medicinal chemist to be an associate director: "The AD, Research Programs – Medicinal Chemist will specifically focus on managing aspects the MJFF preclinical research portfolio with an emphasis on the development of therapeutically viable molecules." Further, they desire "[d]irect experience in central nervous system drug development with an understanding of critical lead molecule selection criteria and ability to understand biological aspects of drug testing."

I really think this is another great position.

Green chile stew!: Got a B.S. in chemistry? Want to be a research technologist in Albuquerque, working on aerosol analytical chemistry? GLP experience would be great.

Monday, February 21, 2011

More on lab relationships

Scully, did you leave the HPLC on?
Photo credit: igossip.com
By popular demand (and the week after Valentine's Day), let's talk about lab relationships. I've always found it a little funny that sometimes, the boss or the administrative rules (or both) will insist that relationships between coworkers not be allowed.

But it just can't be helped, I think. When you get younger people together and heap a bunch of pressure for productivity on top of them, a certain percentage will turn to each other for comfort and understanding. Who better to talk to about your problems than someone who's going through them at the same time, with the same people? Add a smidgen of mutual attraction to that mix and you've got yourself a serious lab romance.

[I should note here that I've never been involved in a lab romance, but I've seen a good number of them. I should also note that most of them are pretty healthy and not too openly demonstrative. We're chemists, after all, not the hot young doctors of Seattle Grace.]

They can have many different outcomes, of course. Some last and grow into long-term relationships with marriage, kids and the whole bit (assuming they solve the two-body problem.) Some end quietly, with no comment given to their friends and awkward silences all around. Some self-destruct spectacularly, with results as entropic as throwing a rotten tomato at a whirring ceiling fan. But get youngish people in an intense, stressful working environment and love (or lust?) will always find a way.

UPDATE: Anon5:13a makes an excellent point. A key catalyst/solvent in these reactions -- ethanol/water mixes. Very, very key.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Do you have a lab spouse?

Do you have a lab spouse? From a CNN article on "work spouses":
Certified career coach Hallie Crawford says you may have a work spouse if:
  • You and a co-worker share information you would only tell a spouse, like personal details about yourself that you don't share with other colleagues. 
  • You confide in them more than anyone else at your office about work issues.
  • You spend a lot of time with them, almost as much time as you do with your spouse.
Gotta say, some of this sounds vaguely familiar. I certainly had a couple lab spouses in my day -- it's a nice way to blow off steam and have a chuckle. It's the explanation by this professor that I find well, obvious:
Work spouses are often labeled as close work friends of the opposite sex, however one researcher finds this is not always the case. 
"We've researched instances where heterosexual individuals have work spouses who are of the same sex - and many examples of work spouses where one is heterosexual and the other is gay, lesbian or bisexual," noted Chad McBride, an associate professor who studies these relationships at Creighton University.
Really? Close friends of the same sex? You're kidding me. (And for my next paper, the moisture content of water!) Work spouses (and lab spouses, too) aren't really about gender; they're about trust and acceptance.

(It's worth pointing out that lab spouses can be a friction point inside a lab environment, especially when they start teaming up against other lab members. Don't do that.)

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Help ACS' Committee on Economic and Professional Affairs

I've had the pleasure of communicating with Lisa Balbes, the 2011 head of ACS' Committee on Economic and Professional Affairs. The CEPA page on the ACS site reads as follows:
The Committee on Economic and Professional Affairs (CEPA) identifies and monitors the needs of the chemical workforce and develops, coordinates, and oversees the implementation of programs and activities to enhance the economic and professional status of chemical professionals.
A question that our e-mail conversations has brought up is this: how can ACS career development programs become better known? Do readers here have experiences with any of the programs (resume review, career counseling, leadership development courses or short courses) they'd like to share? If your experience was positive, did you tell your friends or colleagues?

A broader question that I'll bring up: what would you like to see in the ACS's career programs? Ideally, what would they look like?

Daily Pump Trap: 2/17/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 15 and 16, there were 110 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 6 (5%) of these positions are academically related. 1 (0.9%) position is from Kelly Scientific Resources.

Merck. Merck. MERRRRRRCK!: 73 of the posted positions were from the folks at Merck and Company. While I think everyone would love to work at Merck as an B.S. analytical chemist or a B.S. biochemist (seriously, folks, these are plum positions), few members of the American Chemical Society wish to work as a senior trade compliance analyst or an accounting supervisor. What is this about?

On the other hand...: Lilly wishes to hire a Ph.D. computational chemist with 2 years experience, minimum. There, wasn't that easy?

See, just like that: Kelly Scientific is hiring for a senior analytical chemist position in Bend, Oregon. Polymer experience is a plus. (For those not in the know, Bend is a hidden gem.)

Interesting: The Catalyst Group is a consulting firm to chemical catalysis companies. They're looking for a  program manager (w/a B.S.+) for 2 programs, the "Catalytic Advances Program" and the "Carbon Dioxide Capture and Conversion (CO2CC) Program." Sounds business and communication oriented. Good luck!

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Spools of copper wire

A list of some small, useful things (links):
  • Lab Monkey has written a great series of posts about what UK chemists do, post-graduation.
  • Sharon has more on the chemblogosphere's favorite hair treatment, Brazilian Blowout. Be sure to check out the contributions of Perry Romanowski of Chemist's Corner (cosmetic chemistry blog.) It's great when experts weigh in on a subject.
  • Fred Lakner wrote an letter that I posted; turns out that he makes naturally-extracted perfumes in his spare time. (via Newscripts)
  • John writes convincingly on "Not Invented Here" and "Invented Here" syndrome. I hate to admit it, but I've seen both in action.
  • Paul Bracher writes about using bystanders usefully in an emergency situation in a lab; in my experience, one person (hopefully smart and level-headed) needs to quarterback the process.
  • Paul Hodges writes about China's potential for a housing bubble; ugh.
  • Lastly, Derek Lowe's post about Professor Pepys and his now-infamous comment has an update where a colleague of the professor says that the comment was tongue-in-cheek. For the professor's sake, I sure hope so.

Process Wednesday: operational qualification

Validation is an aspect of working in a manufacturing facility that's a little foreign to a novice industrial chemist. Our Process Wednesday mentor-by-literature, Neal Anderson, writes in the 1st issue of Organic Process Research and Development of 2011* about how to validate a process (defined by Anderson et al. as "the cumulative efforts to demonstrate reliable process and product quality.)

In part of that article, Anderson covers the steps necessary to ensure that the equipment works. He calls these steps "design qualification", "installation qualification" and "operation qualification." It's the last that I wish to focus on for today's post, because it's so simple and yet so important. Operational qualification, Anderson writes, is "confirming that the equipment installed operates correctly. OQ can include checking that required temperature ranges and stirrer speeds can be achieved, that nitrogen and air are supplied suitably, or that materials can be transferred from one part of a system to another without leaks. Often water or solvent is used as a surrogate for process streams to demonstrate that the equipment can perform as required."

He then goes on to describe a few situations in which OQ was key:
With virgin manufacturing facilities OQ is critical. For example, prior to a manufacturing startup, unsuccessful attempts to transfer water from one reactor to another identified a plugged transfer line. The transfer pipe in question had been blanked off for effective welding during construction, and the blank had not been removed. [snip]

Similarly, to prevent condensers, including glass lab equipment, from plugging during reflux it is important to select coolant temperatures above the freezing points of solvents such as t-BuOH (mp 25°C) and dioxane (mp 12°C). The transfer of acetic acid (mp 16°C) from a tanker into a process facility building was stopped when the ambient temperature became unusually cool; the transfer line was lagged with heat tape to melt the plug of AcOH and complete the transfer. Often physicochemical characteristics have been overlooked.
It never ceases to amaze me how Mr. Murphy will hide away in a reactor or a pipe somewhere in your facility. It's the job of the process chemist to find him and chase him somewhere else.

Finally, I wish to thank all the people who contributed to make last week's cGMP post such a wonderful read. I am so grateful to everyone who commented, especially those who took the time to explain such an arcane subject to a willing audience.

*Anderson, N.G.; Burdick, D.C.; Reeve, M.M. "Current Practices of Process Validation for Drug Substances and Intermediates." Org. Process. Res. Dev. 2011, 15, 162-172.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Everything's ooooookay

From the latest issue of C&EN. an update on ACS dues and member benefits:
Dues. [snip] These recommendations included monthly or quarterly (as opposed to annual) dues payment options; discounts for certain groups of members, such as high school teachers, perhaps based on wages or the economy of the home country; discounts during the first few years of membership, when the risk of nonrenewal is particularly high; institutional memberships; and bundling of dues with meeting registration.
Survey data and input from society members indicate that the top three member benefits are scientific information, networking, and professional advancement.
The task force reviewed member feedback on the full range of ACS services and determined that satisfaction with ACS is quite high among members. However, the task force also learned that while journals, Chemical & Engineering News, Chemical Abstracts Service, and national meetings consistently rank as the most popular and important ACS services, most members are unaware of the full range of ACS benefits. The task force recommended that more input should be solicited from members about the benefits they would like to have rather than simply asking members to rate the benefits presently offered. The recommendation was also made that benefits should be better publicized.
I think it's about time to extend the unemployment dues waiver to 3 years, but that's just me. It'd be interesting to know what the "certain groups of members" was.

I would love to see (and I could probably get) a report on the satisfaction of ACS members with the Society. I assume that the satisfaction levels look like a bell curve, with the median member being 1) employed and 2) reasonably satisfied with getting their copy of C&EN in the mail. But I also imagine that at the left end of the bell curve, there are those who are extremely dissatisfied with some of the policy directions of ACS as well.

I'd also like to know what kind of professional advancement the ACS offers; that's something that I'm not quite fluent on. But time (and e-mails) will probably solve that one.

Daily Pump Trap: 2/15/11 edition

Good morning! Between February 10 and February 14, there were 28 new positions posted on the ACS Careers website. Of these, 15 (54%) are academically connected.

Catalysts!: Rennovia is a catalyst startup company; they're looking for (it appears) 2 Ph.D. chemists with experience in catalysts, one very senior (5+ years experience) and one a little less senior (3+).

Fizzy!: Pepsi is looking for a senior scientist to work on "creating data based insight and foundation knowledge of the volatile chemical composition of PepsiCo beverages, foods, ingredients and packaging. The individual will be responsible for conducting volatile analyses, instrument maintenance, and collaborating with product, process, ingredient, quality, and packaging scientists." Sounds like they're looking for an analytical chemist.

Sheep!: Industrial Research Limited is "one of New Zealand’s leading scientific research organisations." They're looking for a Ph.D. organic chemist with experience in carbohydrate chemistry for a 2-year contract. (International candidates considered.)

Golly gee!: USEPA is looking for, well, a senior manager, I think. Why don't you decide for yourself: "EPA ORD is seeking a senior science manager to fill a Branch Chief position in the National Risk Management Research Laboratory (NRMRL) in Cincinnati, Ohio. This position will serve as the Branch Chief for the Systems Analysis Branch within the Sustainable Technologies Division of NRMRL." What does that even mean?

Well, they're happy to tell you: "The Branch Chief reports to the Division Director and exercises supervisory management responsibilities over staff members; develops, implements and conducts research programs in the field of life cycle assessment including methodology and impact assessment developments, and development of sustainable supply chains for biofuels; assists and advises the Division Director in the formulation of research goals and objectives; promotes effective use of all administrative resources." Yeah, that. Um, good luck!

Monday, February 14, 2011

Happy Valentine's Day!

A great place to have a sandwich
Photo credit: AlbuquerqueDailyPhoto.com, H.M. Vanderbeek
Happy Valentine's Day to all of you out there, and especially to my wife. She's the best mate and companion a man could ask for. I am incredibly blessed.

Want to work in China?

As Anon021420110159a notes, today's issue of Chemical and Engineering News has an interesting article by Jean-Francois Tremblay on the potential of US pharma chemists working in China. A few things from the article I didn't know:

They'll help you out: "Wang notes that ChemPartner provides any recruits who don’t speak Chinese with the support of an administrative assistant who can take care of odds and ends such as opening a bank account, house hunting, and so on. The company also arranges lessons for new hires who want to learn Chinese." Now there's a service that I wouldn't immediately expect (re: the administrative assistant), but I suppose that it makes sense. Wonder if it's true?

Oh, dear: This comments about Chinese Ph.D. students is interesting and more than a little frightening:
“We are also interested in fresh Ph.D.s from the U.S. because they tend to be more productive and better at solving problems than Chinese ones,” says Peng Cho Tang, HEC’s chief scientific officer. Tang spent most of his career in companies performing innovative drug research in the U.S. but has managed research labs in China for the past six years. He has observed that most Chinese doctoral students in China spend most of their time in the lab not conducting research, but instead producing start-up materials not easily procured in China.
I'm going to guess that this problem with precursor synthesis isn't widespread. If so, the Chinese graduate education system is going to have some real issues -- gee, isn't that what summer students are for? (Kidding, kidding!)

Oh, no, that's not how you do things: "BrightGene’s core business is the manufacture of difficult-to-synthesize generic active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs), and it uses the cash generated by this business to run several research programs for innovative pharmaceuticals." No, that's not right. The modern way is that the profits generated by your manufacturing business should be used for executive perks and bonuses -- that's more like it.

Do US chemists want to work in China? The article summarizes some of the positives and negatives of working there (relatively easy employment, low pay, new language and culture). I can't say I have not contemplated it, but (as every PRC national in the US knows) it's no fun leaving home and (extended?) family to go try to make a buck and gain some experience. For those thinking about it, this article is worth reading.

Friday, February 11, 2011

Interview: C&EN's Bethany Halford, on the "Too Many Ph.D.s" problem

I hope that all of you have read Bethany Halford's article "Doctoral Dilemma" in the January 31, 2011 issue of C&EN. I am terribly pleased that Dr. Halford (and her bosses at C&EN) were willing to participate in an e-mail Q&A about the article. The answers below have been formatted for posting and checked by her for accuracy.

Also, Dr. Halford will be visiting the comments section a few times today, so feel free to post questions to her in the comments.

Chemjobber: About how many people did you ultimately interview?

Bethany Halford: I spoke to or emailed with about 30 different people for this story.

CJ: Among the range of responses, what percentage would you estimate to be kinda-sorta optimistic about their chances of finding a position? What percentage were looking at leaving chemistry altogether?

BH: The job seekers I spoke with all found the search process to be very frustrating, but they were all still plugging away, although I’d have a hard time saying they were optimistic. None, however, seemed to want to leave chemistry altogether. There were a number of people—although not necessarily among the unemployed—who felt that the employment problems facing chemists are the same employment problems facing the entire country at the moment. Many were optimistic that things would turn around in time.

CJ: How hard did you have to look to find someone that was willing to provide an optimistic quote?

BH: Not hard at all. There are plenty of people out there who don’t think there’s an oversupply of Ph.D.s. In fact, I’d say most of the people in my first round of interviews didn’t think this was a newsworthy topic.

CJ: What was the range of emotion? Did you hear from people that were genuinely angry?

BH: Some people are genuinely angry, but I’d say for most people frustrated is a more accurate adjective. Getting a Ph.D. can be a long, hard slog. Long hours with little reward. It’s not good to find out that the light at the end of the tunnel is a train.

As chemists, we all can’t help but see how central chemistry is to our everyday lives. And so there are many of us, myself included, who entered graduate school thinking that with a Ph.D. in chemistry we could do something we enjoyed, make some sort of contribution to society, and still make a decent, steady living. To find that’s not necessarily the case is really disheartening.

CJ: Professor Hoveyda seems to be suggesting that US graduates might try looking elsewhere in the world -- is this a correct reading of his statement?

BH: I think that is the correct reading of his statement. And I think that strikes Americans as an odd proposition. But he has a point--it’s really not so foreign a concept to most people in the world.

I should add, however, that he also suggested reorganizing the way academic research is done in the U.S.—as one of your commenters suggested—so that there were more research associates (fulltime, reasonably paid positions).

CJ: Did you hear from employers who were bucking the trend, i.e. saying we can't get enough of __?___ kind of scientist?

BH: Anecdotally, some people said that there was a need for more analytical chemists, but it’s not really something I focused on. I didn’t want to end up rewriting Susan Ainsworth’s excellent story on the demand for chemists, “Cautiously Optimistic”.

CJ: For me, anyway, your article has kind of settled the argument for me, as much as I didn't want to believe it. What are the next questions that we need to be asking?

BH: It’s interesting that you say that, because I’m not sure the argument is settled for me. Supply is indeed going up but I’m not sure about demand. One thing that got cut from the piece—according to the most recent ACS salary and employment survey (2009), unemployment is higher for bachelor’s and master’s chemists than it is for Ph.D.s. The same holds true for new graduates at all levels, according to preliminary data in ACS’s 2009 survey of starting salaries for chemists and chemical engineers. Still, there’s no doubt about it; it’s harder for chemists to find work now than it’s been in quite some time. If there’s one thing I think we should really be thinking about, it’s how can we make a chemistry Ph.D. a more versatile degree?

CJ: I know you're not a soothsayer, but what signs would say to you that the negative trends might be reversing themselves?

BH: I’m not sure. Fewer people trying to jump ship and become science writers? Fewer people reading the Chemjobber blog?

CJ: Anything you'd like to say to the CJ readership, now that you're not limited by space?

BH: I like to say thanks to everyone who took the time to read my story. I appreciate that you’re busy and your time is valuable. I’d also like folks to know that we pay close attention to your feedback at C&EN. If there’s something you like or don’t like in the magazine, please don’t hesitate to write us. Also, my colleagues and I do read this blog and the comments herein. We are doing our best to listen to what you have to say.

CJ here again. Huge thanks to Beth for her time and being willing to answer questions -- and thanks again for writing a pretty great article about the situation. Best wishes to all of us. Don't forget, if you have questions for Beth, leave them in the comments!